Hps vs New L.E.D.s

MANGOBICHE

Well-Known Member
850-950 ppfd and overlap is this the actual spectrum?
Whats the energy draw like on say a couple of the 267 set-ups?
Also if you dont mind me asking whats the max size cobs come in atm that are PROVEN like white you mention?
 

Olive Drab Green

Well-Known Member
850-950 ppfd and overlap is this the actual spectrum?
Whats the energy draw like on say a couple of the 267 set-ups?
Also if you dont mind me asking whats the max size cobs come in atm that are PROVEN like white you mention?
http://www.tastyled.com/

Everything you need to know is there. 1200 is the maximum PPFD a typical cannabis plant can use. At 1500, photoinhibition and other issues start to occur.
 

MANGOBICHE

Well-Known Member
ok obviously i have some research to do......i just figured out my brewer
my old one was weak man...

But if i can figure out soil dynamics i can handle this im sure. I always avoided led's because one of my fave breeders told me to just stick with my current gear until leds are similar in pricing as hid equip lmao.
 

MANGOBICHE

Well-Known Member
I have a few plants in various stages of growth..............i wanna try one of these badboys man....seriously, btw thankyou for taking the time to explain this to me. I am sincerely interested, you kidding me man, If i could light up all 4 rooms and my basement and have less than a 400 electric bill id be very very happy like elmer fudd huntin wabbits!
 

Olive Drab Green

Well-Known Member
I have a few plants in various stages of growth..............i wanna try one of these badboys man....seriously, btw thankyou for taking the time to explain this to me. I am sincerely interested, you kidding me man, If i could light up all 4 rooms and my basement and have less than a 400 electric bill id be very very happy like elmer fudd huntin wabbits!
Fuck, yeah, man. Ain't no bullshit, either. But you are right, startup is expensive.
 

Olive Drab Green

Well-Known Member
7 post in a row.

Yep. Time to cut him off. He's had enough.
What the fuck are you even bitching about? This is a forum, where people converse, and derive information. The information you have is incorrect and I urge you to do your research in order to be properly informed, or risk looking severely retarded.
 

Dankistino

Well-Known Member
I love how two alt accounts run by the same person typing in the same moronic, uneducated, childish fashion try to pass it off as two different people agreeing to the same lame point that is in fact not even remotely accurate.

Once again proving me 100% correct.
you're a silly clown. you go from not having a clue about lighting to accusing folks of phony posts Youre as credible as your butt hurt protests are cringe worthy. Only an idiot claims to be "100%" correct" based on fantasy and denial.
 

Olive Drab Green

Well-Known Member
@Olive Drab Green what kind of yield do you pull from 267w/COB? How many sq/ft can you cover with that? It took me 700+ watts/COB to throw down >1000PPFD in a 4x4
What amperage and how many emitters? I get ~850 PPFD from one. 36v, 3500k, 80 CRI, Top Bin CXB3590 driven at 2150mA. I suspect you are driving multiple emitters at like, 700mA and are using some other older or weaker emitter. You definitely don't need 700w for 1000 PPFD.
 

HydoDan

Well-Known Member
Exactly. And I've done exactly that. There is no discernible difference at all. But that doesn't stop the whole "COB crowd" from bowing up in the chest and insulting everybody hand over fist because they spent a ton of money on them.

Simple fact is: They make no difference at all.

The real promise of COB lighting is probably 10 years away. I'm thinking by then, they're going to be increasing the efficiency of LED's a good bit. I'm thinking that the power savings in the futrure is going to be closer to the 40% mark, and that along with lower cost as they go more main stream, will be the end of HPS / MH.
You ignorance is showing again.. go educate yourself... then come back...or don't!
 

TheChemist77

Well-Known Member
Just wondering what the best gram per watt average is for those of you using LED?? under hps,mh, or both ive heard claims of 1.5 gpw,never seen it personally, my best was with 1 600watt hps and 1 600 watt mh over a 4x6ft table and i hit just short of 1.3 gpw... with the ceramics first run using 2 315watt over the 4x6ft table so 630watt total and got 800 grams dry weight 1.4 gpw..each run after its gone up,, i wonder if 2 gpw is possible with ceramics? is 2 gpw acheivable with hps,mh or both? if so were is the proof? those of u running LED please tell us ur best gpw..i assume that 2 gpw is achievable with LED, but who has actually reached the 2gpw mark? and is there any proof,,not just claims???
 

Olive Drab Green

Well-Known Member
Just wondering what the best gram per watt average is for those of you using LED?? under hps,mh, or both ive heard claims of 1.5 gpw,never seen it personally, my best was with 1 600watt hps and 1 600 watt mh over a 4x6ft table and i hit just short of 1.3 gpw... with the ceramics first run using 2 315watt over the 4x6ft table so 630watt total and got 800 grams dry weight 1.4 gpw..each run after its gone up,, i wonder if 2 gpw is possible with ceramics? is 2 gpw acheivable with hps,mh or both? if so were is the proof? those of u running LED please tell us ur best gpw..i assume that 2 gpw is achievable with LED, but who has actually reached the 2gpw mark? and is there any proof,,not just claims???
I will let you know at the conclusion of this grow. I haven't finished one yet under these, but I have never had the plant grow so big in all stages compared to the LED panels I've used, and I have never had a seedling or veg'ing plant push trichomes on fan leaves under those old panels like I am not. The size of the plant from seedling on up is relatively exponentially larger and more rapid under just one of these 89w COBs than it ever was under 2 "450w" panels drawing 206w each. The PPFD and my observations correlate and help me conclude that these COBs in this setup are equivalent to the productivity under a 400-600w HPS.
 

Aaron Forshaw

New Member
How can you really say they are the way to go ??? people are getting decent results with cob' tech its not going to stop there look at the stocks ? Cree has leveled off and is dropping could 2018 bring out a better lighting technology ??
Well if we look at our advancements from 10 years ago YES Cree cobs will be the HPS of the led industry

With all the fairy tales and lies we see and here daily Yes even from growers on here claiming unreal yields specially with cobs soon anyone can really say yes its better efficient.. But it lacks in penetration and with that yield more efficient less yield ???

Kinda sounds like a moot point but is it ??? Lets have a look HPS you need AC units cause of the heat ??? well i have grown now for over 35 years consistently and only start indoor growing in end of oct with fresh air in 6 - 8 k rooms no AC needed actually use the heat for my benefit

Point being is claims you need to cool down your room and ventilation there for operating costs are more ???
Well when we look at normal grow room design ventilation / Fresh air is one of the most important parts of any design or properly built grow rooms and even tents have i vents

i can post millions of pictures of heat stressed Cob grows so again another well orchestrated lie
that LED or cob does not produce heat truth is all power sources produce heat if that wast not the case WTF would a person need a heat sink for ??

And last is how tight has a person gone worrying about 1 - 3 dollar savings a month on power cause that is what it really comes down to pennies
From the moment you took your first breath was the moment sometime in the future you will take your last breath

Same thing applies with everything including lights from the moment its turned on its slow path to death is going to happen sooner or later

So which is better well it comes down to what are you growing in a bread box or a green house or a regular room ..
work with what you got learn try new things which means yes even new lighting

But truth is there is really no better LED Cob or HPS find the one that suits you and that is it

Makes me sick when i here Hid destroyer or cob,
is so much better .. its not it never has been its just another light source an what may work good for your situation here one plant grow 1000 watts over 8 pound what is that for GPW anyone ??? you know anyone with them Einstein skills lol

Yup cob destroyer lol View attachment 3805460

Have a great day
I bought my first hid in 1972 ....fluors before that ...So I have some experience with old technology...
I ran our co-op from 96-2015.. All with hid.. well over a thousand plants a year..
I've had my COBs for roughly 2 months..I don't need Einstein
to tell me which is superior... Experience tells me. Oh yeah, light bill is down over $20 per month.. not $3..
Have you run cobs?? Where are the millions of pics of heat stressed plants under cobs? How many heat stress pics under hid can you find? Show me.. convince me..I've run both!! Have you??[/QUOTE
How can you really say they are the way to go ??? people are getting decent results with cob' tech its not going to stop there look at the stocks ? Cree has leveled off and is dropping could 2018 bring out a better lighting technology ??
Well if we look at our advancements from 10 years ago YES Cree cobs will be the HPS of the led industry

With all the fairy tales and lies we see and here daily Yes even from growers on here claiming unreal yields specially with cobs soon anyone can really say yes its better efficient.. But it lacks in penetration and with that yield more efficient less yield ???

Kinda sounds like a moot point but is it ??? Lets have a look HPS you need AC units cause of the heat ??? well i have grown now for over 35 years consistently and only start indoor growing in end of oct with fresh air in 6 - 8 k rooms no AC needed actually use the heat for my benefit

Point being is claims you need to cool down your room and ventilation there for operating costs are more ???
Well when we look at normal grow room design ventilation / Fresh air is one of the most important parts of any design or properly built grow rooms and even tents have i vents

i can post millions of pictures of heat stressed Cob grows so again another well orchestrated lie
that LED or cob does not produce heat truth is all power sources produce heat if that wast not the case WTF would a person need a heat sink for ??

And last is how tight has a person gone worrying about 1 - 3 dollar savings a month on power cause that is what it really comes down to pennies
From the moment you took your first breath was the moment sometime in the future you will take your last breath

Same thing applies with everything including lights from the moment its turned on its slow path to death is going to happen sooner or later

So which is better well it comes down to what are you growing in a bread box or a green house or a regular room ..
work with what you got learn try new things which means yes even new lighting

But truth is there is really no better LED Cob or HPS find the one that suits you and that is it

Makes me sick when i here Hid destroyer or cob,
is so much better .. its not it never has been its just another light source an what may work good for your situation here one plant grow 1000 watts over 8 pound what is that for GPW anyone ??? you know anyone with them Einstein skills lol

Yup cob destroyer lol View attachment 3805460

Have a great day :)
That is the CON with LED's. The technology is like computers, something better and fancier comes out every 6 months. Its always best to do research, every grower faces different situations. So what will suit you best? But in my experience LED's have provided better quality over HID, my yield was slightly less but my next run I will be adding 2 630w DE LEC/CMH to go along with my 3 bar 600w 3590B cree cobs. wish me luck
 

Dankistino

Well-Known Member
Just wondering what the best gram per watt average is for those of you using LED?? under hps,mh, or both ive heard claims of 1.5 gpw,never seen it personally, my best was with 1 600watt hps and 1 600 watt mh over a 4x6ft table and i hit just short of 1.3 gpw... with the ceramics first run using 2 315watt over the 4x6ft table so 630watt total and got 800 grams dry weight 1.4 gpw..each run after its gone up,, i wonder if 2 gpw is possible with ceramics? is 2 gpw acheivable with hps,mh or both? if so were is the proof? those of u running LED please tell us ur best gpw..i assume that 2 gpw is achievable with LED, but who has actually reached the 2gpw mark? and is there any proof,,not just claims???
bro do your own research. you cant expect folks to assuage your uneducated suspicions.



greengenes pic
 
Top