"Government Motors" A failure? Think Again.

jeff f

New Member
I will admit, some you guys on these boards make me think pretty hard yo.
well i hope i am included in one of the guys that make you think. although i am very hard on you at times .

anyway, my first 2 lessons in economy happened in econ 101. was a university of del. professor. he said number 1 all economic principles are considered, "everything else being equal". 2. everything else is never equal.

reading charts is great, but making changes according to them can be disaster.

you claim the medical private sector has failed and it is market breakdown. i would argue it is the market that must save it and the govt caused the current situation.

when govt told doctors you can only charge X dollars per procedure, it was the beginning of the end. so if a doctor has a medicare patient who needs a procedure, and it cost him 80 but the govt will only pay 65, the doctor must make up the 15 bucks somewhere else. if the doctor wants to make a cent for his time, he has to over charge the next person in line who, more than likely has insurance or is paying cash. either way, if you lose money on one procedure you have to make it up on another.

that has completely bastardized the system. causing costs to rise for other services and blah blah blah.

and notice, the further the govt gets into medical, the more the costs are driven up. ever since forever, the more govt, the more cost. its a giant cost shifting scheme that has failed miserably. a server has to be compensated for the cost of his service, period. if not, they arent in business.

nothing they are promising now is actually gonna reduce cost.

they fucked up the system and we want them to take over more of the system....doesnt make sense.
 

beardo

Well-Known Member
Death panels, I mean healthcare makes sense, we have to fund our defense budget somehow and people are enjoying longer and longer retirements.
 

fallinghigh

Well-Known Member
typical modern republican" awww fuck you and your American Dream and hopey changey thing working for ya"....its working great NAZI fuck try and take it Cival War Part 2 wtf do you think would happen...you would all fucking die every last stupid ingnorent mother fucker
Well that's a cheery american sentiment!!! Awwww, the American Dream. But wait, oh knowz, it's 2011!!!1 I'm pretty sure that the American Dream was only counted in age by dog years, and now he's been dead for some times. looks:(

but don't worry, there is a new dream already available in American stores now. Go pick up your kit today, and add money!
 

NoDrama

Well-Known Member
typical modern republican" awww fuck you and your American Dream and hopey changey thing working for ya"....its working great NAZI fuck try and take it Cival War Part 2 wtf do you think would happen...you would all fucking die every last stupid ingnorent mother fucker
 

mame

Well-Known Member
you claim the medical private sector has failed and it is market breakdown. i would argue it is the market that must save it and the govt caused the current situation.

when govt told doctors you can only charge X dollars per procedure, it was the beginning of the end. so if a doctor has a medicare patient who needs a procedure, and it cost him 80 but the govt will only pay 65, the doctor must make up the 15 bucks somewhere else. if the doctor wants to make a cent for his time, he has to over charge the next person in line who, more than likely has insurance or is paying cash. either way, if you lose money on one procedure you have to make it up on another.

that has completely bastardized the system. causing costs to rise for other services and blah blah blah.

and notice, the further the govt gets into medical, the more the costs are driven up. ever since forever, the more govt, the more cost.
You see, this sounds like it could be true - until you look at other countries and realize that they have more government intervention in the Healthcare sector and they pay significantly less than we do.
 

NoDrama

Well-Known Member
You see, this sounds like it could be true - until you look at other countries and realize that they have more government intervention in the Healthcare sector and they pay significantly less than we do.
Do they use the US Dollar when they pay for healthcare? Do those countries that have awesome public funded healthcare have cheap gasoline? Do they pay less taxes than we do overall? If they have cheap healthcare then they must have expensive something else to subsidize the healthcare. You can't run a Deficit forever.
 

mame

Well-Known Member
Do they use the US Dollar when they pay for healthcare? Do those countries that have awesome public funded healthcare have cheap gasoline? Do they pay less taxes than we do overall? If they have cheap healthcare then they must have expensive something else to subsidize the healthcare. You can't run a Deficit forever.
What makes you say that? Gas prices in Europe are in no way related to European healthcare if that's what you're trying to say(Does Canada pay high gas prices like what's found in Europe? No, gas is a bit more expensive than the U.S. but not like what's found in Europe)...

The numbers are what? $7400-7500 per person in the U.S. vs (depending on the country) $3500 cost for care per person(from all sources)? That's a huge difference. France, for example, uses what's basically a single payer system similar to U.S. medicare - sure they pay higher taxes - but overall they're paying less per person for healthcare than we are. Is it so hard to believe that France is taxing their citizens enough to keep their system going that you assume their system is causing deficits? OUR system is causing deficits and theirs is proven to cost half as much... If people want Universal healthcare (most Americans) than what argument is there against moving to a more cost effective system?

And about Death Panels... Well, I'll just quote Krugman:
I said something deliberately provocative on This Week, so I think I’d better clarify what I meant (which I did on the show, but it can’t hurt to say it again.)

So, what I said is that the eventual resolution of the deficit problem both will and should rely on “death panels and sales taxes”. What I meant is that

(a) health care costs will have to be controlled, which will surely require having Medicare and Medicaid decide what they’re willing to pay for — not really death panels, of course, but consideration of medical effectiveness and, at some point, how much we’re[AS IN THE GOVERNMENT, PEOPLE CAN STILL BUY CARE THAT THEY CAN AFFORD] willing to spend for extreme care

(b) we’ll need more revenue — several percent of GDP — which might most plausibly come from a value-added tax

And if we do those two things, we’re most of the way toward a sustainable budget.
The whole "Death Panel" thing was basically Krugman saying that if the government is going to control costs, they'll need to draw the line somewhere... Is that wrong? You anti-government spending types should be happy that the government would be willing to draw that potentially politically damaging line; It shows control and it shows the government really is committed to not only making care universal but doing so at a fair price to tax payers.
 

NoDrama

Well-Known Member
population wise what are the three largest countries in the world? Do they have "Free" healthcare?

France pays more than we do, but gets healthcare, sounds correct. If you want to talk about single payer healthcare you have to talk about a way to pay for it, currently unsustainable so we will all have to be taxed more to sustain it in the long run. perhaps we can just print more money to pay for it?

rationing of health care is what Krugman is getting at, AKA Death Panels. You can try to spin it any other way but its a group of people who will be deciding who deserves to live and die, a Death Panel. Maybe we should call them life panels instead, since they will be deciding who gets to live just as much as who gets to die, although I think with the economy as it is and getting worse they will opt for death in all but the most simple cases.
 

mame

Well-Known Member
population wise what are the three largest countries in the world? Do they have "Free" healthcare?

France pays more than we do, but gets healthcare, sounds correct. If you want to talk about single payer healthcare you have to talk about a way to pay for it, currently unsustainable so we will all have to be taxed more to sustain it in the long run. perhaps we can just print more money to pay for it?
They pay more to the government than we do but for every person who pays for health insurance in the U.S. they could have gotten essentially the same care for half the cost overall. Also, they aren't just closing the coverage gap, they're also saving those who would have coverage anyway a lot of money. You're saying it's unsustainable, but I feel like your argument is really just that you dont believe in universal care and so no one should be getting taxed for anything... Again, you're in the minority on this one. Besides, you probably already have Health insurance... You'll save money with a universal system.

rationing of health care is what Krugman is getting at, AKA Death Panels. You can try to spin it any other way but its a group of people who will be deciding who deserves to live and die, a Death Panel. Maybe we should call them life panels instead, since they will be deciding who gets to live just as much as who gets to die, although I think with the economy as it is and getting worse they will opt for death in all but the most simple cases.
It's only a rationing of what the government is willing to pay for; They are not barring anyone from paying for their own care. If you want to pay for a better policy, no one is stopping you. If you want to buy an expensive surgery, no one is stopping you.
 

ChronicObsession

Well-Known Member
Help me FDD, this guy is attacking me wahhhhhhh! he said "FUCK ME" wahhhhhhh! Where's the real evidence that you support behind me being a Nazi? I'm not a *real* Nazi fuck... LMAO! If you can't argue without name-calling, don't argue at all douche-i mean dude.
typical modern republican" awww fuck you and your American Dream and hopey changey thing working for ya"....its working great NAZI fuck try and take it Cival War Part 2 wtf do you think would happen...you would all fucking die every last stupid ingnorent mother fucker
 

NoDrama

Well-Known Member
It's only a rationing of what the government is willing to pay for; They are not barring anyone from paying for their own care. If you want to pay for a better policy, no one is stopping you. If you want to buy an expensive surgery, no one is stopping you.
So then the healthcare you are paying for by paying taxes isn't really healthcare is it? I mean if your paying for "HEALTHCARE" and then someone arbitrarily decides that they aren't going to provide the services that you already paid for thats what we call Fraud, Failure to meet expectations of a Contract. I would just get a Lawyer and sue the gov't for stealing my money and then not providing the service that money is to go towards. After they send you home to die, they are still going to tax you for providing a non existent health service. Only 2 things you can't avoid in life, death, and taxes, why let the government have control over the death part too?



Fuck that, I will just take my own chances with my own money, live life in a healthy way and try to be careful to avoid accidents. I bet that by eating right, avoiding certain health pitfalls and getting exercise, I can live a pretty good life with little health maintenance or major surgeries from doctors who must get permission from Big Brother first.

I currently have no health insurance, self employed can be a bitch. If I get real sick i will just go to the E-Room and then never pay the bill and make all you fuckers with insurance subsidize me. Its legal.
 

mame

Well-Known Member
So then the healthcare you are paying for by paying taxes isn't really healthcare is it? I mean if your paying for "HEALTHCARE" and then someone arbitrarily decides that they aren't going to provide the services that you already paid for thats what we call Fraud, Failure to meet expectations of a Contract. I would just get a Lawyer and sue the gov't for stealing my money and then not providing the service that money is to go towards. After they send you home to die, they are still going to tax you for providing a non existent health service. Only 2 things you can't avoid in life, death, and taxes, why let the government have control over the death part too?
When you have private insurance they do basically the same sort of thing, telling you what surgeries and shit you can get and how much out of pocket it'll cost, etc. How is it any different? My mouth was hurting like a son of a bitch a while back and the dentist told me the pain was caused by my wisdom teeth. He recomended I get them pulled but told me my insurance doesn't cover the operation. My pain killers and whatnot were covered or my visits were covered or some bullshit but not the actual operation... Nearly $500 out of pocket. How is this any different than what the government would be doing? I think you're just buying into the "it's my choice!" mantra when in reality, whether it's private or public the basic plan is called "basic" for a reason... They're going to turn you down for something (or at the very least charge you out of pocket, which is what "death panels" would ultimately have you doing).
Fuck that, I will just take my own chances with my own money, live life in a healthy way and try to be careful to avoid accidents. I bet that by eating right, avoiding certain health pitfalls and getting exercise, I can live a pretty good life with little health maintenance or major surgeries from doctors who must get permission from Big Brother first.

I currently have no health insurance, self employed can be a bitch. If I get real sick i will just go to the E-Room and then never pay the bill and make all you fuckers with insurance subsidize me. Its legal.
lol...

If you were someone with health insurance and you knew people did this and it cost you even MORE money, would you really be okay with it? Don't pretend you think it's even remotely moral to take advantage of the system like that... You know just as well as I do that that shouldn't be happening and because we aren't going to turn people down when they show up to the E-room dieing(or whatever) the only logical step to take would be to make sure everyone has health insurance so you know everyone is paying into the system.

Just to be clear, I'm not hating on you for doing what you gotta do but what do you think happens when people are doing this on a grand scale(15% of the population has no health insurance)?
 

NoDrama

Well-Known Member
When you have private insurance they do basically the same sort of thing, telling you what surgeries and shit you can get and how much out of pocket it'll cost, etc. How is it any different?
The insurance companies are at least upfront about it, its all explained in the book you get from them, and its quite a read, but its all in there. And they let you know how much a premium increase is going to be, so you have the opportunity to purchase insurance elsewhere. With govt healthcare your going to get long waits, more taxes, less care and the possibility of no care at all if you are in poor health. The tax increases will be small at first, but once they are in effect they won't go away, in fact some of it will be appropriated for "other" things the government needs money for. All in the name of Healthcare, its amazing what kind of shit would have little oversight with a cute fluffy bunny name like Healthcare attached to it. You won't have a choice on the tax increases either, youll pay or you go out on a stretcher.
 

NoDrama

Well-Known Member
If you were someone with health insurance and you knew people did this and it cost you even MORE money, would you really be okay with it? Don't pretend you think it's even remotely moral to take advantage of the system like that... You know just as well as I do that that shouldn't be happening and because we aren't going to turn people down when they show up to the E-room dieing(or whatever) the only logical step to take would be to make sure everyone has health insurance so you know everyone is paying into the system.

Just to be clear, I'm not hating on you for doing what you gotta do but what do you think happens when people are doing this on a grand scale(15% of the population has no health insurance)?
To be clear I have never done that, but since its totally legal, I can, and might do it, I don't see it happening anytime soon though. i come from a long line of extremely long lived people who all died of OLD AGE. A reuninon in my family is like stepping into a time machine and going back a hundred years. I have Grandparents still alive. Gamma on Moms side is 106, grandpa died at 101. Gramma on dads side is 98, still taking care of herself and is employed, enjoys going to the Casinos. Grandad died at 96. Mom just ran a 26 mile marathon, she's 71 last month, dad is still working in the oil business at 76, he got kind of fat so that has affected his health some, he just bought a brand new 21 foot fishing boat and has already put it in the water by himself. Only one person has died out of any aunts or uncles, poor auntie Jenny, she got stomach cancer and died a few years ago in her 60's. other than that all them old fuckers are still around telling stories of their service in WW one and two. One of my uncles turned 76 today and is on his 11th marriage and 14th kid.


BTW $500 for dental work is nothing, I have $30,000 into mine 5 years ago. i grind my teeth when i sleep, been doing it for a long long time (prob longer than you have lived).
 

mame

Well-Known Member
To be clear I have never done that, but since its totally legal, I can, and might do it, I don't see it happening anytime soon though. i come from a long line of extremely long lived people who all died of OLD AGE. A reuninon in my family is like stepping into a time machine and going back a hundred years. I have Grandparents still alive. Gamma on Moms side is 106, grandpa died at 101. Gramma on dads side is 98, still taking care of herself and is employed, enjoys going to the Casinos. Grandad died at 96. Mom just ran a 26 mile marathon, she's 71 last month, dad is still working in the oil business at 76, he got kind of fat so that has affected his health some, he just bought a brand new 21 foot fishing boat and has already put it in the water by himself. Only one person has died out of any aunts or uncles, poor auntie Jenny, she got stomach cancer and died a few years ago in her 60's. other than that all them old fuckers are still around telling stories of their service in WW one and two. One of my uncles turned 76 today and is on his 11th marriage and 14th kid.


BTW $500 for dental work is nothing, I have $30,000 into mine 5 years ago. i grind my teeth when i sleep, been doing it for a long long time (prob longer than you have lived).
Damn your family lives forever... Almost everyone in my family dies long before 100, Or 80 for that matter. The last person to die in my family, my grandfather, died a couple years ago and he was like 68-69(can't remember exactly... shame on me!) of a heart attack. Although most of the older generation in my family both A) smokes cigarettes and, B) has diabetes so I guess it remains to be seen if it's genetic or mostly lifestyle... Hopefully lifestyle lol...
 

jeff f

New Member
When you have private insurance they do basically the same sort of thing, telling you what surgeries and shit you can get and how much out of pocket it'll cost, etc. How is it any different? My mouth was hurting like a son of a bitch a while back and the dentist told me the pain was caused by my wisdom teeth. He recomended I get them pulled but told me my insurance doesn't cover the operation. My pain killers and whatnot were covered or my visits were covered or some bullshit but not the actual operation... Nearly $500 out of pocket. How is this any different than what the government would be doing? I think you're just buying into the "it's my choice!" mantra when in reality, whether it's private or public the basic plan is called "basic" for a reason... They're going to turn you down for something (or at the very least charge you out of pocket, which is what "death panels" would ultimately have you doing).

lol...

If you were someone with health insurance and you knew people did this and it cost you even MORE money, would you really be okay with it? Don't pretend you think it's even remotely moral to take advantage of the system like that... You know just as well as I do that that shouldn't be happening and because we aren't going to turn people down when they show up to the E-room dieing(or whatever) the only logical step to take would be to make sure everyone has health insurance so you know everyone is paying into the system.

Just to be clear, I'm not hating on you for doing what you gotta do but what do you think happens when people are doing this on a grand scale(15% of the population has no health insurance)?
the difference is, you could have bought better insurance.

lets say we go govt HC. and the death panels (exactly what krugman said and meant cuz he said it more than once) deny a poor person coverage for certain procedures. the rich person still gets the coverage cuz he pays for it.

my question is, isnt that the same as being denied coverage?

a few things you arent considering. 1 the number of people without coverage (15% your number) how many just dont buy the insurance although they can afford it?

2 most poor people are fat, unhealthy, and dont lead healthy lifestyles. you willing to pay for them?

3 you ever talk to the irs about a tax problem? now, think of that conversation and imagine you are really sick, trying to get your coverage or bill straightened out.

4 go to any emergency room in a poor area. i recently was in for chest pains. thought i was having a heart attack. there was one "recipient" of medicaid (welfare insurance) who was pissed off because the doctor wouldnt GIVE her tylenol for her 12 year old child that had a "cough". after repeatedly telling her where she could purchase tylenol, the woman finally stomped out. another kid was in because he hurt his foot playing basketball. he walked in, barely limping, not crying and laughing with his buddies and obviously was not in any "emergency" situation. while this is anectdotal, it is happening everywhere and is exactly what is driving up the cost for everyone else.

mame, one thing your charts will never point out is that when you give someone something for free, they will forever want more free stuff. then when you cant get it for free anymore, they will riot in the street. greece

sorry i am ranting.....but there is so much bullshit being dished out on this medical stuff its pathetic.

i heard earlier today that the AMA is reversing its decision to back obamacare. thanks for telling us 2 FUCKING YEARS TOO LATE.:cuss:
 
Top