hydrostore BULLSHIT

midwestmmj

Well-Known Member
ok guys you organic growers, how many of you ph??
ive been told by every single salesperson in a growstore that i need to ph my supersoil. they tell me im not maximixing my plants and if i phed i would have much better results, they also tell me about there nutrient regiments, which i dont believe one of em even grows. he said he uses a 14 bottle organics feeding regiment. now comeon if your growing organic keep it simple dumbass no need to reinvent the wheel, foliar for every little thing. you went organic to put mother nature back in charge, so why arent you doing that??

anyone ever get the feeling talking to someone that they are just some pretentious fuck that grows way "better" than anyone else? and then u think about it and it makes no sense? am i doin somthing wrong not phing my water?what do u guys think about a 14 bottle regiment? i think they get mad when i tell em i can do 3-4 runs in my tent for under 100$although i do give em nutes if they show it using non phed general organics. fuck bottles, supersoil all the way!!!
thoughts, questions, comments, trolls??
 

grizlbr

Active Member
I go with KISS! What works for you. I started with 3 year old MiracleGrow Blue . ph'd switched to MG red plants were usta blue even if ph was high. 14 $5 = $70 more than I spend all summer. You will go with whatt works for you. If I thought i needed something I used aspirin, Epsom salts and tums
 

tip top toker

Well-Known Member
The one thing i've always noticed about growing cannabis, you can make it as simple or complicated as you like. You'll still get cannabis at the end though. I myself tend my plants for say 10 minutes once a week, but i try not to get stroppy at folk fiddling around with things every hour of every day, if that's what they do, well that's what they do, i'll not let it get in the way of what i do.
 

pandan

Active Member
Ok you are spraying shots in every direction here- attacking a lot of targets.

About PH- yes you absolutely always in every growing style have to think about it if not get it perfect. Having the nutrient in the water isn't enough to make it available for the plant to use. Think of it this way, you could have pork to eat right, but if it's a live uncooked pig you can't just bite in to it. You have to have it under the right conditions for your body to use (cook it). I'm not a chemist so I can't give a big description of how it works (i doubt you want to read all that anyway) but each element in the nutrient mix has an ideal PH where the plant can get it the best as well as a minimum and maximum PH range to be in or the plant simply cannot draw it in. For potting mixes you get a bit more of a buffer than other styles but you still cannot break the laws of the chemicals reactions therefore having the right or wrong PH can mean a world of difference.

As for doing organics to be simple- no way! Organics isn't about 'mother nature'- mother nature is when man didn't order the damned seed off the internet and plant it. It's about using organic life to grow the plant instead of trying to just fabricate and short-cut everything. Instead of getting a chemist to try to make some super duper synthetic nutrient mix that jumps right in the plant through the magic of science- organics uses science to say stuff like 'hey there are micro organisms that our chemical regimes kill which are actually our friends, if we cultivate this organic life they will provide enzymes and work the medium to unlock nutrients' etc. So really the easy option is to just get a bottle of chemical shit and dump it in- which is why i'm not using organic yet.

14 bottle regime? Dude must really love plants and putting work in. Do you have to? No of course not. Is it wrong to? Hell no. Good on him if he wants to really grab hold of the steering wheel and work the gears. I worked at a wholesale nursery for a while and hated the fact that so much of it seemed to be divorced from understanding and tending to the plants. It was all just slow release fertilizer pellets and no attention to plant health and growth.

Anyway you want easy use Coco Coir. Look it up
 

midwestmmj

Well-Known Member
The one thing i've always noticed about growing cannabis, you can make it as simple or complicated as you like. You'll still get cannabis at the end though. I myself tend my plants for say 10 minutes once a week, but i try not to get stroppy at folk fiddling around with things every hour of every day, if that's what they do, well that's what they do, i'll not let it get in the way of what i do.
i know but when tending cannabis, paying so much per grow is just unwise, help end poverty, lower your cost of goods :) 30$ for 1k+worth of pot or 500 for 1.2k worth of pot, you can see what im getting at
keep it green
 

midwestmmj

Well-Known Member
Ok you are spraying shots in every direction here- attacking a lot of targets.

About PH- yes you absolutely always in every growing style have to think about it if not get it perfect. Having the nutrient in the water isn't enough to make it available for the plant to use. Think of it this way, you could have pork to eat right, but if it's a live uncooked pig you can't just bite in to it. You have to have it under the right conditions for your body to use (cook it). I'm not a chemist so I can't give a big description of how it works (i doubt you want to read all that anyway) but each element in the nutrient mix has an ideal PH where the plant can get it the best as well as a minimum and maximum PH range to be in or the plant simply cannot draw it in. For potting mixes you get a bit more of a buffer than other styles but you still cannot break the laws of the chemicals reactions therefore having the right or wrong PH can mean a world of difference.

As for doing organics to be simple- no way! Organics isn't about 'mother nature'- mother nature is when man didn't order the damned seed off the internet and plant it. It's about using organic life to grow the plant instead of trying to just fabricate and short-cut everything. Instead of getting a chemist to try to make some super duper synthetic nutrient mix that jumps right in the plant through the magic of science- organics uses science to say stuff like 'hey there are micro organisms that our chemical regimes kill which are actually our friends, if we cultivate this organic life they will provide enzymes and work the medium to unlock nutrients' etc. So really the easy option is to just get a bottle of chemical shit and dump it in- which is why i'm not using organic yet.

14 bottle regime? Dude must really love plants and putting work in. Do you have to? No of course not. Is it wrong to? Hell no. Good on him if he wants to really grab hold of the steering wheel and work the gears. I worked at a wholesale nursery for a while and hated the fact that so much of it seemed to be divorced from understanding and tending to the plants. It was all just slow release fertilizer pellets and no attention to plant health and growth.

Anyway you want easy use Coco Coir. Look it up


i do agree with most of what you said, but i believe there are exemptions. ever heard of subcools super soil? no ph necessary, dechlorinated tap water and the occasional aact. sometimes for a boost i topdress with wormcastings. to me its about quality not quantity, and i can say with his recipe im very happy to say the least with the ease and vigor of the grow and of my plants.
 

tip top toker

Well-Known Member
i know but when tending cannabis, paying so much per grow is just unwise, help end poverty, lower your cost of goods :) 30$ for 1k+worth of pot or 500 for 1.2k worth of pot, you can see what im getting at
keep it green
This is completely irrelevant. You might as well just start arguing seed choices now. If someone wants to spend more on their grow, that's their decision, it doesn't make them "wrong" or something.


Now you're saying for you it's about quality not quantity, yet are bashing a guy for putting lots of time and effort and money into his plants for what could be exactly the same kind of reasoning. Have you seen his plants to determine what he is achieving with his methods?
 

pandan

Active Member
Help end poverty? What the hell you talking about man?
And you didn't feature in potency or grow time. You could yield the same amount in shit weed you know- i know cause i did it on my first grow. I got no less than 12 pounds from my first grow using a 600w hps but it was at best only half as potent and tasty as what i grow now.
 

CEEJR

Well-Known Member
One of my plants was growing really slow and was sickly in FFOF and FF nutes, so I checked the pH and it was over 7 . Started using pH corrected water to 6.5 and after 1 week the plant started to really take off so based on that I think it's very important to adjust and maintain proper pH.
 

midwestmmj

Well-Known Member
ok the help end poverty was a joke, sorry to rile yall up about it, and no i havent seen his plants, im sure they look awesome though, i guess what im getting at is that it can be very simple, its only as hard as you make it. ive done hydro and with that i did ph my nutrients... every time. with organics the roots and benefitial microbes work together to make a living root soil food web where the microbes adjust your ph. you can look that up if you want.

and pandan u meant 12 oz off one 600 right, 12 lbs is total bs. and by quality i mean potency
 

midwestmmj

Well-Known Member
at tiptop, no way am i trying to start a fighting thread, if it does ill unsub, i dont do drama, online or in real life.
 

tip top toker

Well-Known Member
ok the help end poverty was a joke, sorry to rile yall up about it, and no i havent seen his plants, im sure they look awesome though, i guess what im getting at is that it can be very simple, its only as hard as you make it. ive done hydro and with that i did ph my nutrients... every time. with organics the roots and benefitial microbes work together to make a living root soil food web where the microbes adjust your ph. you can look that up if you want.

and pandan u meant 12 oz off one 600 right, 12 lbs is total bs. and by quality i mean potency

Well yes, this is a widely held view of growing marijuana, it can be simple or it can be complicated. Thread seems like an awfully roundabout way of putting that.

And maybe by quality the guy who seems to be overdoing things, maybe he considers quality as potency and flavour and appearance and whatnot. Potency does not equal quality, there's more to it than that.

If you don't do drama online then i don't see why you created this dramatic thread. I'm out.
 

Capt. Stickyfingers

Well-Known Member
Having the nutrient in the water isn't enough to make it available for the plant to use.

Organics isn't about 'mother nature'- mother nature is when man didn't order the damned seed off the internet and plant it.
1. He clearly stated he was growing in organic soil with plain water feeding (supersoil). So your comment about nutrient in the water is pointless.
2. Organics absolutely is mother nature. The soil is mixed with natural organic materials that break down naturally, as if it were outside. Plain water feedings + organic soil = mother nature.
 

midwestmmj

Well-Known Member
1. He clearly stated he was growing in organic soil. So your comment about nutrient in the water is pointless, besides I'm sure he knows that little fact already.
2. Organics absolutely is mother nature. The soil is mixed with natural organic materials that break down naturally, as if it were outside. Plain water feedings + organic soil = mother nature.

thank you! its crazy the amout of different ways you can grow, the mos important thing i think is to do what you believe in, i guess i am kinda takin it hard on the guy, just tryin to make a buck prob... plus everything in the store went up like crazy, lights 1k setup 350, now 550...wow.
i could only imagine the arguements that a biodynamic grower would experience, unfamiliar with biodynamics? check out demeter biodynamics, they are the standard.
 

pandan

Active Member
Oh shit! Yes 12 oz of course! Been working too much and getting really tired.

And about subcools soil not needing PH adjust- I didn't know that but it sounds very interesting.
I see you do understand what I was trying to say and I do get what you were saying too.
 

pandan

Active Member
Ok the nutrients do nothing unless they are water soluble or at least can travel in the water in to the plant- that's why I said "in the water".

And about mother nature that is BS- Did mother nature make that plastic pot you use? Did mother nature make those pipes and the chemicals in your tap water? Fuck no. Does mother nature get you to grab a bunch of random useful shit and chuck it in the pot? Mother nature didn't even make the plant because it's been bred by man for thousands of years.
So just because it works in the same sort of manner as what can naturally occur- that absolutely does NOT mean it's natural. I got another one- where the fuck do you find subcool's potting mix just all done up waiting for a plant to grow in the unspoiled wilderness? No where because it's not natural to be that awesome. Did you know that more than 80% of propagules in nature do not germinate? That's nature for you there.

Yes if you have a medium which can put itself in the right PH or condition to uptake nutrients then you don't have to work so hard to get it right- that's just common sense. My point remains that the elements being present alone isn't enough.
 

midwestmmj

Well-Known Member
thanks pandan, reminds me of a video i watched a while ago that was organics vs synthetics, we could go on all day. i totally understand that a 12/12 cycle is not mother nature nor is anything in a totally artificial environment. i guess what i should have said is i put mother nature in control as much as i can, which is probably what anyone can say here, synthetic or organic. peace guys. :peace:
 

Dan Kone

Well-Known Member
ok guys you organic growers, how many of you ph??
ive been told by every single salesperson in a growstore that i need to ph my supersoil. they tell me im not maximixing my plants and if i phed i would have much better results,
I always try to stay away from enlisting hydro store employees for growing advice. Most of these guys only know what other customers and product sales reps tell them.

But they are sort of right on this point. Your soil does need to be in a certain ph range for plants to take in the nutrients. However if dolomite lime is part of your soil mix, you should be ok. It has the same effect as ph down.

I'm on well water which changes a bit from year to year so each year I need different amounts of dolomite lime in my soil. To test it is pretty easy. Take a few 1 gallon pots full of your soil mix, add and measure different amounts of lime to each pot. Test the run off water. Which ever pot gives you the desired ph (high 5 to low 6 range) is your winner. Take the amount of lime you added to that pot and multiply that number by gallon size of your pots, multiplied by your total number of pots. That's how much dolomite lime you need to add to your soil mix.

they also tell me about there nutrient regiments, which i dont believe one of em even grows. he said he uses a 14 bottle organics feeding regiment. now comeon if your growing organic keep it simple dumbass no need to reinvent the wheel, foliar for every little thing. you went organic to put mother nature back in charge, so why arent you doing that??
Well I would use a 14 bottle organic feeding regiment too if I was buying nutrients at cost like they most likely are. You can do the same, and it'll probably turn out great, but if you're buying it at or near retail, you're more than likely going to get a diminishing return on your purchase.

Plants need enough nutrients to be in good health and not have deficiencies. Nothing more. If you're doing that cheaply through a soil mix, then doing it through a fancy expensive nutrient product line is a waste of money.

Hydro stores stay in business by selling nutrients, grow mediums, and light bulbs. Those three things are what keeps them in business. But nutrients are their bread and butter. That's where they make the majority of their money. Ever notice that when you go into a hydro store the nutrients are prominently displayed in the middle of the store? That's how they get your money.

No one buys new fans, ac units, ph censors, ballasts/hoods, pumps, or dehumidifiers every cycle. You buy those things and then you have them. But these stores are being sustained by repeat business. Stuff you need to buy every cycle. That's nutrients. Those nutrient companies are constantly sending sales reps into the store to hype up their products and give the employees free samples so they say kind words about them to their customers.

But the truth is that those one time purchase environmental controls have way more to do with the quality of your end product than nutrients do. They just aren't marketed as much.

You don't need a 14 bottle product line to grow great bud. You need to give your plants enough nutrients to remain healthy. You need a constant temp in the 70s, an elevated level of Co2, a humidity range in the 40s, the proper amount of light, a clean room that you keep bug free, you need to give your plants the attention they need to optimize their health, and train them in order to optimize your space.

You do those things and you'll grow better much better bud than someone who just goes out and spends a lot of fancy nutrient product lines. If your plant starts to develop deficiencies, then address them with the appropriate nutrients. But if they are already healthy, you're don't need that stuff.

Supersoil should give your plants enough of the nutrients they need to stay healthy especially if you're top dressing during flowering.

anyone ever get the feeling talking to someone that they are just some pretentious fuck that grows way "better" than anyone else? and then u think about it and it makes no sense?
IMO that's them trying to present themselves as authorities on the subject so you buy what they tell you to. An effective sales technique. When I worked sales jobs in college, I did the same thing.

am i doin somthing wrong not phing my water?
I think you have been this whole time and you just didn't know it.

what do u guys think about a 14 bottle regiment?
I think it's awesome if you work in a hydro store where you can buy stuff at cost and get it free from sales reps. I think it's snake oil if you're buying it at retail.

i think they get mad when i tell em i can do 3-4 runs in my tent for under 100$although i do give em nutes if they show it using non phed general organics. fuck bottles, supersoil all the way!!!
thoughts, questions, comments, trolls??
If it ain't broke, don't fix it. If your soil are sustaining healthy plants, why bother spending more money to get bottled nutrients? Hydro store employees don't know as much as they pretend to know for the most part. If they were really that good at growing, why are they working a retail job?

sorry for the long winded post
 

Prefontaine

Well-Known Member
ok guys you organic growers, how many of you ph??
ive been told by every single salesperson in a growstore that i need to ph my supersoil. they tell me im not maximixing my plants and if i phed i would have much better results, they also tell me about there nutrient regiments, which i dont believe one of em even grows. he said he uses a 14 bottle organics feeding regiment. now comeon if your growing organic keep it simple dumbass no need to reinvent the wheel, foliar for every little thing. you went organic to put mother nature back in charge, so why arent you doing that??

anyone ever get the feeling talking to someone that they are just some pretentious fuck that grows way "better" than anyone else? and then u think about it and it makes no sense? am i doin somthing wrong not phing my water?what do u guys think about a 14 bottle regiment? i think they get mad when i tell em i can do 3-4 runs in my tent for under 100$although i do give em nutes if they show it using non phed general organics. fuck bottles, supersoil all the way!!!
thoughts, questions, comments, trolls??
seriously man if you just use a basic ph kit to put our water around where you need to be, your soil will be fine, i use a general hydroponics ph kit when water with nutes at least until i figure out what the nutes do to the water ph level, and i just use aerated tap water the rest of the time, my tap water is 7.4-7.8 ph and when i use my electronic 10 dollar soil ph meter that seems to keep the soil around 6.2 or 6.3, so yeah its good to have the ph stuff around so you can check when you see a problem, but yeah growing weed is only as expensive as you make it, so hell yeah 100 bucks a crop woot!
 
Top