VIANARCHRIS
Well-Known Member
Canada's marijuana prescription business raises some ethical questions
By Solomon Israel, CBC News Posted: Apr 27, 2017 5:00 AM ET Last Updated: Apr 27, 2017 5:00 AM ET
Specialty clinics where doctors write prescriptions for legal marijuana have become a booming business across Canada. (Matthew Staver/Bloomberg)
Solomon Israel
Solomon Israel is a producer and writer for CBC News, based in Toronto. He's been on the business news beat since 2011, with stints covering technology, world, and local news. More recently, Solomon has been covering issues related to marijuana legalization. He can be reached at [email protected], or on Twitter: @sol_israel.
Across Canada, specialty medical clinics are making money within the government's legal medical marijuana regime by acting as middlemen between doctors, patients and licensed marijuana producers.
The clinics are in the business of taking referrals from doctors and arranging consultations with physicians who assess potential patients and write prescriptions for those who qualify. Clinic staff then educate those patients on how to use medical marijuana, and register them with the licensed medical marijuana producers who will ultimately provide the patients with legal cannabis by mail.
Some of the clinics also receive money from those licensed producers, raising questions about medical ethics and transparency.
The clinics are needed to bridge the gap between patients who could benefit from medical marijuana and doctors who are hesitant to prescribe it, according to patient advocate Jonathan Zaid, executive director of Canadians for Fair Access to Medical Marijuana.
"Each clinic operates a bit differently, but a well-operated medical cannabis clinic plays an important role for patient access, especially considering many physicians still feel uncomfortable authorizing medical cannabis," he said.
How one clinic business works
Canadian Cannabis Clinics has 17 locations in Ontario and two in Alberta. It opened its first clinic in St. Catharines, Ont., in 2014.
"The response was overwhelming, because there was a very strong pent-up demand both from patients as well as from local physicians who had patients who wanted medical cannabis but were unable to assist them," said Ronan Levy, the company's chief corporate officer and general counsel.
A Canadian Cannabis Clinics location on Danforth Avenue in Toronto. (Doug Husby/CBC News)
He said patient assessments at Canadian Cannabis Clinics are performed by physicians who work as independent contractors. Those doctors bill provincial health insurance programs for their consultations, and the clinic takes a percentage of that billing to cover administrative costs.
"We make money like any other medical clinic," he said.
If a patient is given a prescription for medical marijuana, clinic staff help them register directly with a licensed producer, then educate the patient about how to use medical cannabis.
Money from licensed producers
Levy said Canadian Cannabis Clinics has contracts with 12 licensed producers, which pay a separate counselling service called CanvasRx that educates patients within the clinics. CanvasRx was previously owned by Canadian Cannabis Clinics, but was spun off and purchased by licensed producer Aurora Cannabis in 2016.
Despite those relationships with producers, Levy said patients can choose any licensed producer they wish.
"But if you happen to register with one of the licensed producers for which we have a contractual arrangement, that licensed producer would pay CanvasRx a fee for that patient."
Seeking growth among veterans, professionals
CannaConnect, another clinic business, takes a targeted approach to finding new patients.
"Veterans [have] become a big focal point for us over the last 12 to 18 months," said CEO Lee Grossman. "I'd say we're the second-largest medical cannabis clinic geared towards veterans in the country."
His company has opened locations in towns and cities with military bases, like Fredericton and Petawawa, Ont.
Promotional materials, including empty containers used to hold medical marijuana grown by licensed producers, is seen on display at a CannaConnect office in downtown Toronto. (CannaConnect)
CannaConnect recently opened a location on the 25th floor of a Bay Street office tower in downtown Toronto to serve the area's white-collar workers.
"These are people living with high-stress jobs," Grossman said. "A lot of stress, anxiety, sleeping issues, and they're often self-medicating on their own without a prescription, so here's a legal option for them to actually obtain a prescription above board."
CannaConnect receives educational grants from licensed medical marijuana producers, and refers clients to what Grossman called "a curated list of recommended producers," although clients are free to choose their own licensed producer.
The educational funding provided by licensed producers helps patients navigate a complex system, said Mark Zekulin, president of Canopy Growth Corporation, which owns multiple licensed producers and is Canada's largest legal medical marijuana company by market capitalization.
"At the end of the day, there is this gap with patients understanding what to do and where to go and how to do it," he said.
Selling patient data
Canabo Medical Corp., a publicly traded company based in Halifax that operates Cannabinoid Medical Clinics across Canada, also uses doctors to assess patients and write their prescriptions, then refers the patients to an educator who helps them choose a licensed producer. Those educators don't receive any funding from licensed producers and "are not directed in any way" to refer patients to a certain producer, said Dr. Neil Smith, executive chairman of Canabo.
"We don't get a kickback from the licensed producer based on whether we get them a script or not," Smith said.
Instead, Canabo collects patient information in a detailed database, then sells the anonymized data to licensed producers who use it for market research purposes, as well as insurance companies.
'Serious ethical concern'
One medical ethicist said he has "some serious ethical concern" about how these clinics operate.
"The clinics that are running don't have any clear oversight," said Kerry Bowman, an assistant professor of bioethics at the University of Toronto.
"You've got a lack of transparency, you potentially have conflict of interest, and you potentially have kickbacks," he said.
"I don't want to paint everyone with the same brush. There may well be clinics out there that are really acting in the best interests of patients, but it's hard to be sure."
"I've heard reports of clinics charging very excessive fees, or not adequately serving patients' needs," he said. "It's important to ensure they provide adequate followup care, as well as not restricting [patients] to a limited list of licensed producers."
By Solomon Israel, CBC News Posted: Apr 27, 2017 5:00 AM ET Last Updated: Apr 27, 2017 5:00 AM ET
Specialty clinics where doctors write prescriptions for legal marijuana have become a booming business across Canada. (Matthew Staver/Bloomberg)
Solomon Israel
Solomon Israel is a producer and writer for CBC News, based in Toronto. He's been on the business news beat since 2011, with stints covering technology, world, and local news. More recently, Solomon has been covering issues related to marijuana legalization. He can be reached at [email protected], or on Twitter: @sol_israel.
Across Canada, specialty medical clinics are making money within the government's legal medical marijuana regime by acting as middlemen between doctors, patients and licensed marijuana producers.
The clinics are in the business of taking referrals from doctors and arranging consultations with physicians who assess potential patients and write prescriptions for those who qualify. Clinic staff then educate those patients on how to use medical marijuana, and register them with the licensed medical marijuana producers who will ultimately provide the patients with legal cannabis by mail.
Some of the clinics also receive money from those licensed producers, raising questions about medical ethics and transparency.
The clinics are needed to bridge the gap between patients who could benefit from medical marijuana and doctors who are hesitant to prescribe it, according to patient advocate Jonathan Zaid, executive director of Canadians for Fair Access to Medical Marijuana.
"Each clinic operates a bit differently, but a well-operated medical cannabis clinic plays an important role for patient access, especially considering many physicians still feel uncomfortable authorizing medical cannabis," he said.
How one clinic business works
Canadian Cannabis Clinics has 17 locations in Ontario and two in Alberta. It opened its first clinic in St. Catharines, Ont., in 2014.
"The response was overwhelming, because there was a very strong pent-up demand both from patients as well as from local physicians who had patients who wanted medical cannabis but were unable to assist them," said Ronan Levy, the company's chief corporate officer and general counsel.
A Canadian Cannabis Clinics location on Danforth Avenue in Toronto. (Doug Husby/CBC News)
He said patient assessments at Canadian Cannabis Clinics are performed by physicians who work as independent contractors. Those doctors bill provincial health insurance programs for their consultations, and the clinic takes a percentage of that billing to cover administrative costs.
"We make money like any other medical clinic," he said.
If a patient is given a prescription for medical marijuana, clinic staff help them register directly with a licensed producer, then educate the patient about how to use medical cannabis.
Money from licensed producers
Levy said Canadian Cannabis Clinics has contracts with 12 licensed producers, which pay a separate counselling service called CanvasRx that educates patients within the clinics. CanvasRx was previously owned by Canadian Cannabis Clinics, but was spun off and purchased by licensed producer Aurora Cannabis in 2016.
Despite those relationships with producers, Levy said patients can choose any licensed producer they wish.
"But if you happen to register with one of the licensed producers for which we have a contractual arrangement, that licensed producer would pay CanvasRx a fee for that patient."
- Entrepreneurs want bite of Canada's marijuana edibles market
- Analysis: Loblaw is covering medical marijuana for workers. Will others follow?
Seeking growth among veterans, professionals
CannaConnect, another clinic business, takes a targeted approach to finding new patients.
"Veterans [have] become a big focal point for us over the last 12 to 18 months," said CEO Lee Grossman. "I'd say we're the second-largest medical cannabis clinic geared towards veterans in the country."
His company has opened locations in towns and cities with military bases, like Fredericton and Petawawa, Ont.
Promotional materials, including empty containers used to hold medical marijuana grown by licensed producers, is seen on display at a CannaConnect office in downtown Toronto. (CannaConnect)
CannaConnect recently opened a location on the 25th floor of a Bay Street office tower in downtown Toronto to serve the area's white-collar workers.
"These are people living with high-stress jobs," Grossman said. "A lot of stress, anxiety, sleeping issues, and they're often self-medicating on their own without a prescription, so here's a legal option for them to actually obtain a prescription above board."
CannaConnect receives educational grants from licensed medical marijuana producers, and refers clients to what Grossman called "a curated list of recommended producers," although clients are free to choose their own licensed producer.
- Analysis: How high will the price of legal pot be?
- While pot fans light up on 420, Bay Street plans for profits
The educational funding provided by licensed producers helps patients navigate a complex system, said Mark Zekulin, president of Canopy Growth Corporation, which owns multiple licensed producers and is Canada's largest legal medical marijuana company by market capitalization.
"At the end of the day, there is this gap with patients understanding what to do and where to go and how to do it," he said.
Selling patient data
Canabo Medical Corp., a publicly traded company based in Halifax that operates Cannabinoid Medical Clinics across Canada, also uses doctors to assess patients and write their prescriptions, then refers the patients to an educator who helps them choose a licensed producer. Those educators don't receive any funding from licensed producers and "are not directed in any way" to refer patients to a certain producer, said Dr. Neil Smith, executive chairman of Canabo.
"We don't get a kickback from the licensed producer based on whether we get them a script or not," Smith said.
Instead, Canabo collects patient information in a detailed database, then sells the anonymized data to licensed producers who use it for market research purposes, as well as insurance companies.
'Serious ethical concern'
One medical ethicist said he has "some serious ethical concern" about how these clinics operate.
"The clinics that are running don't have any clear oversight," said Kerry Bowman, an assistant professor of bioethics at the University of Toronto.
"You've got a lack of transparency, you potentially have conflict of interest, and you potentially have kickbacks," he said.
"I don't want to paint everyone with the same brush. There may well be clinics out there that are really acting in the best interests of patients, but it's hard to be sure."
- Liberals table bills to legalize pot, clamp down on impaired driving
- How to legalize marijuana, without ever saying 'marijuana'
"I've heard reports of clinics charging very excessive fees, or not adequately serving patients' needs," he said. "It's important to ensure they provide adequate followup care, as well as not restricting [patients] to a limited list of licensed producers."
