No worries, thanks.ya man...i wish i had something for ya on that one...but i got zip
No worries, thanks.ya man...i wish i had something for ya on that one...but i got zip
hehe, my life is just "tough lately" is the best way to put it. I have been dealing with some health issues as well as money issues, started a new job though, and have zero free time. That's sort of the simplified version. I'll spare you the rest of the details .thanks for your feedback man...i really appreciate it...youre absolutley right too...in my earlier threads i eluded to using full size trash bins as root chambers...the last design i posted was stacked 5 gallon buckets....intuition told me the trash bins would be best...but my already-owned grow tent told me to use the buckets :0(
that being said, what do you think about the use of trash bins? how about my manifold/solenoid set up? do you think the 2nd mister furthest from the solenoid will see the same action as the one closer to it? any other reccomendations you can make on improvements will be much much much appreciated
i just got into this a few weeks ago...i never really put 2 and 2 together as far as HPA vs LPA...to be quite honest i didnt even know there was a difference...i thought aero was aero...i currently grow in an LPA/NFT bucket system and ive gotten decent results...but i want the pompoms...once i found HPA i immediately fell for it...im a water guy by trade and by hobby...HPA is the best of both worlds for me...im really anxious to get the design finalized where i know im going to get top notch results without me wasting 5 or 6 bills for a glorified NFT system...i already have a glorified NFT system
again, thanks for the input man...much respect to the ones before me
when are you commissioning your system? are you still waiting on parts?
BD
It's not cheap, but the do make see through PVC that will take high pressures (you could visually see how much air is in there, and it might be fun to watch it compress as it takes the shocks). I understand that you are trying to make a DIY water hammer arrestor. Honsetly, by the time you buy the clear PVC it will probably cost the same amount as a commercial arrestor however. Perhaps you can just add on a tire type air valve and apply pressureized air once in a while to top it off? Trying to calculate the air absorbed into the water would be really hard considering the constant changing psi and temperature fluctuations. What if you made it a screw off type tube that you could unscrew once a month or so, let fill with air, and screw back on? You may have to have a way to purge any bubbles that get into your lines afterwards, but it could work.Am I missing something or is that how long it would take to fill the volume with an unrestricted flow?
I have my 1/4" line running through a 1" tee, the tee then has 12" of 1" pvc that is capped on the end. The flow rate is about .5 gal per day at a resting pressure of 100PSI this then falls to 80PSI when the solenoid opens and returns to 100PSI when it closes. I didn't do any flow calcs (Renolds number, etc) because the system was small enough that I didn't believe they were necessary.
I know that eventually the pressure in the system will cause the air to be absorbed by the water and the water hammer will be back.
Sounds like it may be easier to just wait and find out as the grow progresses.
Thanks.
The design may work, if you can get the shower curtain to adequately seal the wood. Perhaps coating with epoxy would be better? I believe a single mister may not be enough to adequeatly cover the entire root mass on all sides, but you can test and see.ok so i rethought the whole root chamber and solenoid thing...here is what im thinking
i make an 18" x 18" x 3' box for each root chamber...i leave one side open and put a 4-6" hole on the top for the net pot...i build it out of plywood and seal the joints with non-toxic sealant of some sort...i then secure insulation to all faces of the inside and then line the insides with shower curtain...on the open side of each box i hang more shower curtain...probably with some velcro stripping...this will be to access each root chamber...each box is painted white....there will be a screen at the bottom of each box and ill put a small pan to collect the DTW and just suck it up with the shop vac every once in a while
1 mister would be installed on the back of each box with one solenoid mounted as close as possible to it...it would all be fed off a common 1/2" manifold supplied by the HPA control box in the other layouts ive posted
my current tent doesnt have the height i need for HPA...ive come to that conclusion...so im going to get another tent...this one a 4'x4'...so with that, im going with 4 plants...i will most likely not scrog depending on how high the tent ends up being
so what do you think? do you think the root chambers are large enough? do you think i will have wood rotting issues? do you think i could just use one solenoid at the entrance of the manifold?
thanks
BD
ok so i rethought the whole root chamber and solenoid thing...here is what im thinking
i make an 18" x 18" x 3' box for each root chamber...i leave one side open and put a 4-6" hole on the top for the net pot...i build it out of plywood and seal the joints with non-toxic sealant of some sort...i then secure insulation to all faces of the inside and then line the insides with shower curtain...on the open side of each box i hang more shower curtain...probably with some velcro stripping...this will be to access each root chamber...each box is painted white....there will be a screen at the bottom of each box and ill put a small pan to collect the DTW and just suck it up with the shop vac every once in a while
1 mister would be installed on the back of each box with one solenoid mounted as close as possible to it...it would all be fed off a common 1/2" manifold supplied by the HPA control box in the other layouts ive posted
my current tent doesnt have the height i need for HPA...ive come to that conclusion...so im going to get another tent...this one a 4'x4'...so with that, im going with 4 plants...i will most likely not scrog depending on how high the tent ends up being
so what do you think? do you think the root chambers are large enough? do you think i will have wood rotting issues? do you think i could just use one solenoid at the entrance of the manifold?
thanks
BD
Coverage from a single mister was my concern as well when I read your post.The design may work, if you can get the shower curtain to adequately seal the wood. Perhaps coating with epoxy would be better? I believe a single mister may not be enough to adequeatly cover the entire root mass on all sides, but you can test and see.
Have you priced stainless water hammer arrestors? The ones I found were $300 & up, I made all the effort to keep brass and copper out of the system, it would seem like such a wasted effort if I installed a brass commercial water hammer arrestor. I'm thinking about V2, with either a screw on top or maybe a 4x cross with a drain valve at the bottom. Maybe I'll just get lucky and it will last the entire grow, purging it at the beginning of the grow wouldn't be a problem.It's not cheap, but the do make see through PVC that will take high pressures (you could visually see how much air is in there, and it might be fun to watch it compress as it takes the shocks). I understand that you are trying to make a DIY water hammer arrestor. Honsetly, by the time you buy the clear PVC it will probably cost the same amount as a commercial arrestor however. Perhaps you can just add on a tire type air valve and apply pressureized air once in a while to top it off? Trying to calculate the air absorbed into the water would be really hard considering the constant changing psi and temperature fluctuations. What if you made it a screw off type tube that you could unscrew once a month or so, let fill with air, and screw back on? You may have to have a way to purge any bubbles that get into your lines afterwards, but it could work.
I believe cavadge listed a reasonably priced one at 80$ or so, but It's a dim memory. I also agree with keeping brass and copper out of the system because the copper reacts with the salts and can reach toxic levels to the plants. However- I have heard a part here and there are really not such a big deal- especially where the nutes are not sitting for long periods of time with such piece. Most of the solution will be sliding by without even really getting up into the arrestor, the little that does I doubt would ever pose a noticeable issue at all. DTW is much more forgiving like that, if you recirculated with copper components it would not be nearly as forgiving.Coverage from a single mister was my concern as well when I read your post.
Have you priced stainless water hammer arrestors? The ones I found were $300 & up, I made all the effort to keep brass and copper out of the system, it would seem like such a wasted effort if I installed a brass commercial water hammer arrestor. I'm thinking about V2, with either a screw on top or maybe a 4x cross with a drain valve at the bottom. Maybe I'll just get lucky and it will last the entire grow, purging it at the beginning of the grow wouldn't be a problem.
The one Cav used was nickle plated with a brass plunger. I may end up using a commercial one but the DIY should work, they used air chambers in residential plumbing for a long time.I believe cavadge listed a reasonably priced one at 80$ or so, but It's a dim memory. I also agree with keeping brass and copper out of the system because the copper reacts with the salts and can reach toxic levels to the plants. However- I have heard a part here and there are really not such a big deal- especially where the nutes are not sitting for long periods of time with such piece. Most of the solution will be sliding by without even really getting up into the arrestor, the little that does I doubt would ever pose a noticeable issue at all. DTW is much more forgiving like that, if you recirculated with copper components it would not be nearly as forgiving.
i keep flip flopping between square vs round, single plant vs multiple...it really all comes down to what is going to work best for me...and right now i cant deal with getting a bigger tent or expanding the space i already useA good way to smooth out this issue is to not use isolated chambers for each plant, but use one larger chamber with multiple plantings. You can take advantage of the larger volume of air, but share it with more than one plant. The trash containers might work for one plant each, but you will still need at least 2 nozzles for coverage.
i totally hear ya on this one...that was a point i was trying to make earlier....in the first manifold design, i had them in series...the last post with the 4 three sided wooden root chambers had a parallel manifold in the back feeding everything at the same pressureIn regards to the manifold situation, if your worried about some shorter lines having more pressure than the longer runs, try balancing the system out by using T's and having a complete circle of mist line in a closed loop. Sort of like the difference between parallel and series if you catch my drift. To illustrate what I'm getting at, say you have 2 misters. Instead of having just a single T off the pump left/right to feed each mister, include an additional T's at each mister, and connect the backside of each T to eachother so you have a big circle with misters at each side. It should help balance out the differences if that made any sense. I am not a fluid dynamics guy, but it makes logical sense in my mind that it would help balance the system out. The loop should have equal pressure at any point, and as long as the line from the T's to each mister is similar in length, they should all have about the same pressure feed. Hope this makes sense, and please anyone correct my thinking if I am wrong.
thanks PF...im not going to go that big as im going to have to stay in the tent i currently have....but im going to go with 20 gallon trash bins...see below for the update n let me know what you think plsPod Size: If you go back and explore Pod Racer's thread he/they were making one large table in the space of your 4. I think if you make it 36 X 36 or better 48 X 48 you will have much better success- and significantly more air space for the mist to expand and fall. I intuit that 18 X 18 is going to create too much dead space in the close corners. I now when Atomizer recommended that I increase my pod size (I went from 18G to 30+G) that the roots really appreciated it.
Short answer - No, the PSW240 is not comparable to the x100.Guys having a problem finding a pressure switch, have the one that BD mentioned but it's 1/4" and all my other components I've sourced so far are 3/8" inch to this point, found Aquatecs PDF, none of the model numbers sync with anything I actually find being sold, is the PSW 240 comparable to the PSW 100X they define in their PDF? If not, or if you just have the stats of it please share. Otherwise I'm going with BD's suggestion for simplicity.
I highly suggest to those that try to build one of these download yED or another diagramming software, lay out your system, and all the connections, otherwise you'll be a-wash in a see of connections.
There is an adjustment screw on the switch, it's obvious and simple once you touch one.Alright, could you do me a favor and give me a once over of how to adjust it once I have it? or point me to manual?
You're going to have to disable the internal pressure switch to run @ 100PSI#PUMP#
You say aquatec but the link is to a different switch#PRESSURE SWITCH#
It's hard to say for sure but I think it should be able to run 14 misters. There are several pieces of data needed to be sure. Making a few assumptions you system lays out like this:I have a question though, do you think that can run 14 misters? Otherwise I was going to go with 10, either way is fine.
It looks like you have the major pieces. If you aren't missing something you'd be the first I don't have any check valves but that's not to say that the "correct" way.Do you see anything missing? I thought the pressure gauge before the accumulator was redundant, can add back if needed, do you need check valves past the pressure regulator?
Yea, it's lot's of fun, but when you get it all together and it's making mist it feels great.And I have to say sourcing parts is definitely the hardest part of this.
I know, these aren't HPA roots. This is a 18G tote. Atomizer pointed out that it was too small for the mist to expand properly. I moved the plants into a 33G tote, adjusted mist cycle to 2 seconds and root hairs developed all over the existing roots. It was cool to see, and reinforced the relationship between mist times and pod volume.
Note the Reptile Basics sourced mist heads are on articulating arms that also swivel. I have found this invaluable for making minor positioning adjustments. IMHO I think your heads are positioned too low. hth