How many people understand the US Constitution?

Rob Roy

Rob Roy

Well-Known Member
UncleBuck said:
that's his terminology for when a black person orders breakfast at a restaurant and tries to pay with cash, like any other customer.
Click to expand...
You're up early.

I'd say offensive force is present when one human makes it clear they'd prefer not to interact with another and the other human persists and forces the interaction to happen.

On the surface, your example sounds like the black person seeking the interaction is not the aggressor, because you shrouded it in racial guilt speak like you like to do.

However if a black person wished to be left alone, and a white person insisted on the interaction, the white person would be the aggressor in that instance. So, it's not about race per se. It's about the person who forcibly insists that an unwanted interaction will be initiated. That person is the one using offensive force.

You're welcome, Poopy Pants.
 
Rob Roy

Rob Roy

Well-Known Member
TacoMac said:
There's no such thing as defensive force. There is defensive action, but not force. Force is always offensive. That somebody has to point that out to you is more than a bit telling.
Click to expand...
Excellent point, Captain Semantics. I bow to your lexicon god and beg forgiveness.

How does that change the gist of what I said ?
 
tampee

tampee

Well-Known Member
DiogenesTheWiser said:
Yeah, I get that Roby Roy is a segregationist and child molester. That's why most of these anarcho types argue what they do. And it's complete fantasy. There's like no chance whatsoever that there'll ever be a "government" that doesn't have coercive power. Human beings are social creatures and as such, government will always be necessary or else life as we know it would cease.
Click to expand...
We had no government in the old west and we did just fine...
 
Rob Roy

Rob Roy

Well-Known Member
DiogenesTheWiser said:
Yeah, I get that Roby Roy is a segregationist and child molester. That's why most of these anarcho types argue what they do. And it's complete fantasy. There's like no chance whatsoever that there'll ever be a "government" that doesn't have coercive power. Human beings are social creatures and as such, government will always be necessary or else life as we know it would cease.
Click to expand...
That wasn't constructive to our discussion.
 
DiogenesTheWiser

DiogenesTheWiser

Well-Known Member
tampee said:
We had no government in the old west and we did just fine...
Click to expand...
Which West? Do you mean the West as in the western side of the Mississippi river? Ohio, Illinois, and Indiana were the West at one point in American history. Is that the West you speak of here?

Mississippi, Arkansas, Louisiana, and Alabama was the Old Southwest at one time in American history.

The West today was not always the West and was not always in American control. Before American control of the land that is the West today, Native American societies dominated and they had governmental systems, albeit unlike Euro-American governmental systems.

Then the U.S. Government invaded and conquered the West, and with it they brought the U.S. Army with them--the most glaring example of government.
 
Rob Roy

Rob Roy

Well-Known Member
UncleBuck said:
a black person trying to buy lunch at a restaurant is not "initiating force".

the racial guilt is all yours, klansman.
Click to expand...
Generally speaking I agree with you, but you conveniently ignore the context of my meaning.

Here let me explain to you slow person and maybe you can connect the dots....

In any kind of human interaction involving property of one person being exchanged for property of another, if the exchange isn't mutual and voluntary and BOTH parties haven't agreed to it...

What would you call it then?
 
UncleBuck

UncleBuck

Well-Known Member
DiogenesTheWiser said:
I think the folks in bleeding Kansas, 1856-65, would disagree with the "just fine" part.
Click to expand...
if you just ignore the slavery and civil war part, the west did just fine.

just like if you ignore the fact that tampee visits child pornogrpahy websites, he is not a pedophile.
 
tampee

tampee

Well-Known Member
DiogenesTheWiser said:
Which West? Do you mean the West as in the western side of the Mississippi river? Ohio, Illinois, and Indiana were the West at one point in American history. Is that the West you speak of here?

Mississippi, Arkansas, Louisiana, and Alabama was the Old Southwest at one time in American history.

The West today was not always the West and was not always in American control. Before American control of the land that is the West today, Native American societies dominated and they had governmental systems, albeit unlike Euro-American governmental systems.

Then the U.S. Government invaded and conquered the West, and with it they brought the U.S. Army with them--the most glaring example of government.
Click to expand...
It was better before the US government/military arrived and forced taxes on free land.
 
Rob Roy

Rob Roy

Well-Known Member
UncleBuck said:
there is no context in which a black man tying to order some lunch at a restaurant is "initiating force", racial segregationist.
Click to expand...

So, you don't think individual humans of any race have a right to decline a human interaction from another person ?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top