HPS vs LED

Status
Not open for further replies.
S

snakedope

Well-Known Member
amneziaHaze said:
Leds 2.6g/w hps1.2g/w
Leds can use more space in a tent because less heat.
Leds live 10x longer thab hps bulbs(less buying new light)
Leds save money in sommer hps saves money in winter
Click to expand...
LEDs 2.6 of bunk weed you need to light every 10 min
Hps 1.2 of dank you take 3 hits your gone
I'll take the 1.2 anyday over led bud.
Also I will sell it probably double or triple that of the led bud which goes for so low these days it's a straight up joke lol
So where's the gpw numbers now
You sell a g for 10 usd and hps bud goes for 25+ haha the irony
 
shishkaboy

shishkaboy

Well-Known Member
Im doing a side by side in a sealed room with co2...
I was offered an opportunity to get this new technology at a discounted rate

Its the first bar style with lights all the way around the edges
 
Last edited:
budolskie

budolskie

Well-Known Member
snakedope said:
LEDs 2.6 of bunk weed you need to light every 10 min
Hps 1.2 of dank you take 3 hits your gone
I'll take the 1.2 anyday over led bud.
Also I will sell it probably double or triple that of the led bud which goes for so low these days it's a straight up joke lol
So where's the gpw numbers now
You sell a g for 10 usd and hps bud goes for 25+ haha the irony
Click to expand...

Why is no one backing your claim bro, is it the same bullshit as hydro weed is shitter then soil weed because its hydro??
 
S

snakedope

Well-Known Member
budolskie said:
Why is no one backing your claim bro, is it the same bullshit as hydro weed is shitter then soil weed because its hydro??
Click to expand...
I noticed a change in smells in organic vs hydro, not saying it's better or not just makes a plants matabolisem and profiles a bit different, also very small margin imo, not worth the debate.
I smoked fire hydro and fire organics.

I don't need no one to back my claim btw, it's opinion i said it already, I don't claim shit cuz you want papers and documents to back it up, and if they are not in line with bugsbee you won't accept it anyway.

Are you saying that the ones that invented this lights, said they are meant to grow leafly greens in "space" are wrong and weed growers who feel nice saving some electric and heat are right ?

We are not claiming nothing, everything straight from the source, no one ever said these lights are meant to flower anything.
 
budolskie

budolskie

Well-Known Member
snakedope said:
I noticed a change in smells in organic vs hydro, not saying it's better or not just makes a plants matabolisem and profiles a bit different, also very small margin imo, not worth the debate.
I smoked fire hydro and fire organics.

I don't need no one to back my claim btw, it's opinion i said it already, I don't claim shit cuz you want papers and documents to back it up, and if they are not in line with bugsbee you won't accept it anyway.

Are you saying that the ones that invented this lights, said they are meant to grow leafly greens in "space" are wrong and weed growers who feel nice saving some electric and heat are right ?

We are not claiming nothing, everything straight from the source, no one ever said these lights are meant to flower anything.
Click to expand...
Loads of fire is done by led lights, i have grown with hps since i started, and more now seem to be using led so if your opinion was true most of the weed about would be shite
 
budolskie

budolskie

Well-Known Member
So i have dropped my light from 24" to 18" but dimmed the light to keep it at 180ppfd which is now under 50% where as at 24" i needed the light on 75% to get the 180ppfd... would that be a good idea ?
 
Billy the Mountain

Billy the Mountain

Well-Known Member
snakedope said:
I noticed a change in smells in organic vs hydro, not saying it's better or not just makes a plants matabolisem and profiles a bit different, also very small margin imo, not worth the debate.
I smoked fire hydro and fire organics.

I don't need no one to back my claim btw, it's opinion i said it already, I don't claim shit cuz you want papers and documents to back it up, and if they are not in line with bugsbee you won't accept it anyway.

Are you saying that the ones that invented this lights, said they are meant to grow leafly greens in "space" are wrong and weed growers who feel nice saving some electric and heat are right ?

We are not claiming nothing, everything straight from the source, no one ever said these lights are meant to flower anything.
Click to expand...
That's good because it's not gonna happen; don't let facts get in the way of an outlandish opinion.
 
S

snakedope

Well-Known Member
Facts ? Share them... Instead of replying at me.
What are those facts you talking about ?
30% flowers that smoke like 5% ?
Fake lab tests ?
Buds that you need to stuff your nose in the jar to even smell ?
Where are all those facts ?
Aside from papers from bugsbee who probably never grown or smoked good dope in his life, what facts you have ?
Are you saying that monsanto and nasa didn't planned this tech as green leaf supplement lights ?
 
budolskie

budolskie

Well-Known Member
snakedope said:
Btw - who even heard of bugsbee before LEDs started to explode ? Hmm... A shill ??
I put my money on it.
Click to expand...

But where is a the hps growers who agree?
Why do people change to led and never look back?


I only heard about bugsbee other day he did a very good job of learning me about dli a ppfd and got me wanting to switch to led on my next run
 
amneziaHaze

amneziaHaze

Well-Known Member
snakedope said:
I noticed a change in smells in organic vs hydro, not saying it's better or not just makes a plants matabolisem and profiles a bit different, also very small margin imo, not worth the debate.
I smoked fire hydro and fire organics.

I don't need no one to back my claim btw, it's opinion i said it already, I don't claim shit cuz you want papers and documents to back it up, and if they are not in line with bugsbee you won't accept it anyway.

Are you saying that the ones that invented this lights, said they are meant to grow leafly greens in "space" are wrong and weed growers who feel nice saving some electric and heat are right ?

We are not claiming nothing, everything straight from the source, no one ever said these lights are meant to flower anything.
Click to expand...
Your opinion contradicts lab tests every lab test will tell you led gives more thc,simply because same wattage will give more light.hps spends a shit tone of energy making ir light

Allsoo led will give you a better light color better designed for plant growth compared to optimised for street light
 
S

snakedope

Well-Known Member
amneziaHaze said:
Your opinion contradicts lab tests every lab test will tell you led gives more thc,simply because same wattage will give more light.hps spends a shit tone of energy making ir light

Allsoo led will give you a better light color better designed for plant growth compared to optimised for street light
Click to expand...
Ok I don't debate lab results which has been proven to be tempered with in every test.
Also it still don't explain how 30% bud is worse then a 15% bud
That alone says thc tests are not worth a dime
In terms of quality of bud and should be totally ignored.
 
budolskie

budolskie

Well-Known Member
snakedope said:
Ok I don't debate lab results which has been proven to be tempered with in every test.
Also it still don't explain how 30% bud is worse then a 15% bud
That alone says thc tests are not worth a dime
In terms of quality of bud and should be totally ignored.
Click to expand...
Where are your 30% and 15% buds to show other wise it just isnt gona convince anyone
 
madvillian420

madvillian420

Well-Known Member
snakedope said:
LEDs 2.6 of bunk weed you need to light every 10 min
Hps 1.2 of dank you take 3 hits your gone
I'll take the 1.2 anyday over led bud.
Also I will sell it probably double or triple that of the led bud which goes for so low these days it's a straight up joke lol
So where's the gpw numbers now
You sell a g for 10 usd and hps bud goes for 25+ haha the irony
Click to expand...
Ah yes the last time i bought weed i said "no sir, i dont want a $250 oz grown under LED, give me one of those $700 HPS zips that i only need to light 1 time"

If youre buying or selling weed for $25 a g (havent paid that since i was getting taxed to shit in high school) because it was grown under HPS, then someone in that equation is getting robbed lol
 
tstick

tstick

Well-Known Member
amneziaHaze said:
Leds 2.6g/w hps1.2g/w....Which isn't important to me. Yield is the worry of the commercial grower, not the small-time hobbyist, like myself.
Leds can use more space in a tent because less heat. Yes, but less heat isn't always the best thing....say, if your growing environment is in a cool basement. If you use only LEDs in that situation, then you will have to add a space heater -which basically negates the efficiency of the light.
Leds live 10x longer thab hps bulbs(less buying new light). Right. But if you have an LED chip go dead, then can you unscrew it and replace it? Bulb fixtures are very user-serviceable in that regard.
Leds save money in sommer hps saves money in winter I agree, but the real savings comes with growing your own -as opposed to buying it. Also, if you use "The Gas Lantern Technique", then you can use HPS much more efficiently. I have done this several times, and it works great.
Click to expand...
I addition to all that, if you use an UNSHIELDED MH bulb or a Ceramic Metal Halide bulb, then your plants will get a pretty decent and steady dose of UV.
 
amneziaHaze

amneziaHaze

Well-Known Member
tstick said:
I addition to all that, if you use an UNSHIELDED MH bulb or a Ceramic Metal Halide bulb, then your plants will get a pretty decent and steady dose of UV.
Click to expand...
It was proven that uv gives only negative effects on plants.and works like a pesticide that is good in 1-60 seconds a day
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top