Is the chlorine from tap water REALLY that bad?

atlantadirect said:
I think the subject is "Does the low level of chlorine in all municipal water harm plants?" So it doesn't matter that your water is different from his, both of your waters will have varying amounts of chlorine. You're right that the levels are different, but it is possible to answer the question in a general manner.

I would say "No, the low levels of chlorine in tap water aren't likely to harm your plants but the other dissolved minerals might. If you are worried about harming the beneficial bacteria in your soil you can evaporate the chlorine out by letting the water sit in an open container for a day or two or by having an air-pump pump air through an airstone in the water for an hour or two or by boiling the water and letting it return to room temperature. I'm not sure how important beneficial bacteria are to hydroponic grows like flood/drain or DWC, but if I knew I had tap water with low ppm I wouldn't even bother to evaporate the chlorine out. It might even help to prevent root rot. I don't know that for sure, but that would be my guess."
Click to expand...

thanks you! much obliged! i have 30ppm out of my tap :) :hump:. so im not worried about anything else besides maybe chlorine, thats why i asked the question. but i dont think i will worry much because of the info you guys have shared with me. it would be one thing if i was going organic but im not. ty for the nice words, im glad your not on the rag.:mrgreen::mrgreen:
 
We TaRdED said:
lets have a little debate. ive hear it does damage to the plants from some ppl and others have said not to worry. what do you think?
Click to expand...

You never had a question see above and your like 3 post aft this said keep debating people.....you didnt want someone to relay to you in a nice way as per your last post to me that any answers to questions...you wanted to debate the topic, I simply point out that its not really a debateable topic and then you start making accusations about my kindness then sugarcoat that but telling the next guy your glad he isnt on the rag? REALLY ....its cute how you play off in the end that you were just asking a question and I was such a bitch and wouldnt help you in a polite way.
 
pinksensa said:
You never had a question see above and your like 3 post aft this said keep debating people.....you didnt want someone to relay to you in a nice way as per your last post to me that any answers to questions...you wanted to debate the topic, I simply point out that its not really a debateable topic and then you start making accusations about my kindness then sugarcoat that but telling the next guy your glad he isnt on the rag? REALLY ....its cute how you play off in the end that you were just asking a question and I was such a bitch and wouldnt help you in a polite way.
Click to expand...


"
icon1.gif
Is the chlorine from tap water REALLY that bad?"

^^my title^^

"so im referring to just to the chlorine aspect of the tap water and nothing else... thanks for your input! :P "

^^third post^^

look, im sure your a nice person. im glad your interested in my thread:mrgreen:. i guess i just got offended. it made me mad when you said i should move my thread to another location, implying that my question was not genuine, your "get it?", shouting at me that "ITS DIFFERENT EVERWHERE", and just i felt an overall animosity from you from your first post. im not here to argue with ppl, i dont need any more problems in my life right now.

its not right for me to call names and put you down, sorry for that.

im sorry that i said that we should debate an undebatable subject, im not that smart, i guess, otherwise i would have know. your right, im wrong, i should probably just end this thread then? what do you suggest i do?:confused:
i dont know any local growers, thats why i come here for my info because the number one rule of growing security is dont tell anyone otherwise you can jeopardizes your freedom. once again, sorry for my ignorance and thanks for correcting me. maybe i need to bongsmilie
 
"i love hi-jacking and its especially great when it takes down a stupid thread"

for the record, this is a quote from pinksensa! it looks like shes at work here. thanks miss pink for all your kind words, and enlightening us on the subject.
 
I wasnt hi jaking...hi jaking is when your comments are completely off subject from the topic, I wasnt being mean or rude or a know it all, I will promise you that if I see a thread with your name on it I wont enter the thread at all, I wont comment, or help otherwise. If I see your comments in a thread Im reading I wont comment on your comments. I am a very nice person and I help everyone as much as I can all the time, Im polite, Im courtesy, I dont say mean things, call people names. Even when I told you that you should have posted in another category I was being polite letting you know that your topic is valid but if you want to debate it you should go into a more debate like area, because everyone responding was giving you advice. As previously stated you wont see me cross threads with you again.
 
I just had to say my tap water is probably around 9 ph . . when testing it almost glows teal without ph down.

So your results will vary for tap water - just check ph.

And personally I let my water sit out in between waterings (I fill up my watering can *after* watering). Just a simply precaution if chlorine does actually matter.
 
pinksensa said:
I wasnt hi jaking...hi jaking is when your comments are completely off subject from the topic, I wasnt being mean or rude or a know it all, I will promise you that if I see a thread with your name on it I wont enter the thread at all, I wont comment, or help otherwise. If I see your comments in a thread Im reading I wont comment on your comments. I am a very nice person and I help everyone as much as I can all the time, Im polite, Im courtesy, I dont say mean things, call people names. Even when I told you that you should have posted in another category I was being polite letting you know that your topic is valid but if you want to debate it you should go into a more debate like area, because everyone responding was giving you advice. As previously stated you wont see me cross threads with you again.
Click to expand...

i know you werent hijaking, but i guess it stirred up some shit and brought us off the subject at hand. maybe im just the one in a bad mood today. maybe i misinterpreted what you were trying to say, or how you were trying to say it.

maybe i should have put it in toke and talk, i just figured it was general growing information plus there is more ppl in here too.

" I will promise you that if I see a thread with your name on it I wont enter the thread at all, I wont comment, or help otherwise. If I see your comments in a thread Im reading I wont comment on your comments."

you dont have to go that far. :neutral: no hard feelings pink, i just felt like you were biting a little so i bit back. seriously NO HARD FEELINGS. you dont have to take it that far. i could care less if you post in a thread that i have posted in. i dont hate you or anything. :peace:
 
yo pinksensa i know its your time of the month so you should go blaze a fatty blunt to ease the cramping pains..
 
I love the guys who will not filter tap water, but collect rainwater in one of those toxic rubbermade plastic trash cans...which toxins do you prefer...I myself don't even inhale
 
Chlorine will evaporate out of the tap water pretty quickly in an open container. But most municipalities now add chloramine. Which does not evaporate out.

The ppm's in most tap municipal processed tap water is too low to hurt plants whether chlorine or chloramine.

We let the water sit out so it can rise closer to room temperature as to not shock the roots.

I strongly suggest a water test to know how to deal with your own water for your garden.

Alkalinity is the most important thing to understand. Ph is not the issue. What is causing it is.

And cannabis utilizes a few ppm of chlorine as a trace element.
 
It depends imo, chlorine and whatever else may be in your tap water means nothing if you're growing in soil. I'd think it may actually be helpful in hydro, all I read about is people adding H2O2 or pool shock to their hydro water, ph of course is important in hydro but it's not even a word in a soil grower's vocabulary.

Here's another perspective for soil growers and water quality. Many of us outdoor growers have used puddles, lake/pond water, collected rain water, anything we can get our hands on and don't have to carry to remote grow locations. Plants grow just as well with that water.

My area has really high chlorine in the water, strong enough you can smell it out of the tap, smells like a pool that was just shocked. These 2x 15gal plants were grown with tap water straight out of the hose and Jack's Citrus, nothing else all the way through to harvest. Never checked ph, let the water sit or filtered it in any way. They eventually pulled 29 zips dry between them.

Outdoor-10-02-2016-Week17-Week7-1.JPG
 
MichiganMedGrower said:
Chlorine will evaporate out of the tap water pretty quickly in an open container. But most municipalities now add chloramine. Which does not evaporate out.

The ppm's in most tap municipal processed tap water is too low to hurt plants whether chlorine or chloramine.

We let the water sit out so it can rise closer to room temperature as to not shock the roots.

I strongly suggest a water test to know how to deal with your own water for your garden.

Alkalinity is the most important thing to understand. Ph is not the issue. What is causing it is.

And cannabis utilizes a few ppm of chlorine as a trace element.
Click to expand...
And you are from Michigan ..home of clean wawa...thanks for the tip
 
GroErr said:
It depends imo, chlorine and whatever else may be in your tap water means nothing if you're growing in soil. I'd think it may actually be helpful in hydro, all I read about is people adding H2O2 or pool shock to their hydro water, ph of course is important in hydro but it's not even a word in a soil grower's vocabulary.

Here's another perspective for soil growers and water quality. Many of us outdoor growers have used puddles, lake/pond water, collected rain water, anything we can get our hands on and don't have to carry to remote grow locations. Plants grow just as well with that water.

My area has really high chlorine in the water, strong enough you can smell it out of the tap, smells like a pool that was just shocked. These 2x 15gal plants were grown with tap water straight out of the hose and Jack's Citrus, nothing else all the way through to harvest. Never checked ph, let the water sit or filtered it in any way. They eventually pulled 29 zips dry between them.

View attachment 3853487
Click to expand...
Cheap charcoal filters remove chlorine, not Floride though...nice bonsai trees
 
bullSnot said:
And you are from Michigan ..home of clean wawa...thanks for the tip
Click to expand...

I moved here 5 years ago. And I actually have a well with really good water. Gotta have a deep well here for quality.

But there was chlorine in the water in my last neighborhood and I used it out of the tap on summer when it was not too cold.
 
bullSnot said:
Cheap charcoal filters remove chlorine, not Floride though...nice bonsai trees
Click to expand...
Yeah I had some in my last house on a well but for drinking water/coffee/tea I just have one of those Brita jugs which does the trick. Everything else gets pool shocked water - lol

Bonsai growing for stealth - lol Funny thing came out yesterday too, the "task force" that put the recommendations together for legalization in Canada is recommending a 4 plant rec limit and 40" (100cm) height restrictions. I have some practice, I'm good ;)
 
bullSnot said:
I love the guys who will not filter tap water, but collect rainwater in one of those toxic rubbermade plastic trash cans...which toxins do you prefer...I myself don't even inhale
Click to expand...
Lol id imagine you dont drink/eat/cook out of aluminum or store food in tupperware huh..
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Spliffy Twojoints
Chlorine and chloramine in water maybe a non-issue?
Replies
11
Views
1K
Jjgrow420
Jjgrow420
S
WATER Questions, Am I doing it totally wrong???
Replies
12
Views
1K
Rocket Soul
Rocket Soul
calvin.m16
POOL SHOCK (HOW MUCH, ANSWERED) *easy*
Replies
1
Views
702
ProPheT 216
ProPheT 216
CuzzoRo
Herbies Mix Grow #3
Replies
0
Views
395
CuzzoRo
CuzzoRo
Woedae
Fool proof seed germination
Replies
7
Views
924
Farmer's Hat
Farmer's Hat
Back
Top