I suppose that depends on what your view of toxic/ poisonous is. Poison to me is something that would cause considerable health concerns. In the view of the science community, I suppose you could label it toxic and poisonous (atleast mildly due nausea/stomach discomfort, and psychological effect) to OP just wait, I know you want to relinquish your previous experience, but u more than likely will leave yourself disappointed, wait at least a week, preferably 2. I found the more you do them they lose their significance, mushrooms imo are not for recreation, although most use them in this sense.