Anyone know what shooting powder and top booster actually are? From the H&G nutrient line?

Samwell Seed Well

Well-Known Member
so if you have the correct amount of P (43ppm), why would you add more K to the mix??? care to elaborate?? and don't forget to tell us what excess K does to other nutrients too.
what is "correct amount of P", you keep going back to this abstract number, when every plant is different, every grow is different

even the same clones can exhibit different genotypes from enviromental stress and all of a sudden changing their eating habits
 

Samwell Seed Well

Well-Known Member
@Samwell Seed Well

you probably subscribe to using Cal/Mg to fix a Mg problem too I'm guessing?
what cal mag thing.... lol

without a lot of other info i u cant answer anything about the cal mag thing

coco 100% strips calcium, coco is reactive this is basic

and your plants use calcium a semi mobile nutrient for literally dozens of biological functions

its broken down into enzymes amino acids other usable forms of calcium

what is the argument

that you dont know why plants need cal or elevated amounts of cal for certian reasons at certain times
 

Samwell Seed Well

Well-Known Member
so funny seeing the pied pipper effects of populism
holy f*ck, that's exactly what i'm saying.

is English your first language? if' it's like your 4th or so, i'll be gentler on you. or are you just slow?

no you said it causes deficienes and argue against using it becuase you couldnt use it without issues

PK boosters are fine

Kelp products are fine

rooting gel is fine, you dont need them

you want them. striaght up

nutrients and additives are often the cheapest thing you can improve to get more out of your time and energy

why would anyone want to grow less, to save 4 bucks on an additve
 

jondamon

Well-Known Member
so funny seeing the pied pipper effects of populism



no you said it causes deficienes and argue against using it becuase you couldnt use it without issues

PK boosters are fine

Kelp products are fine

rooting gel is fine, you dont need them

you want them
That’s not what he’s said. Sorry.

He said too much P or K can antagonise other nutrients.

my advice to anyone setting out growing for the first time is choose a basic nutrient that has everything the plant needs and become familiar with environmental control and manipulation.

Many new growers often look for a new bottle of something when in reality it could be an environmental issue causing problems.

Learn your nutrients

master your environmental variables.

THEN when you feel you’ve exhausted the resources available to you then look to add 1 additional product and see if it makes a difference.
 

Samwell Seed Well

Well-Known Member
so if you have the correct amount of P (43ppm), why would you add more K to the mix??? care to elaborate?? and don't forget to tell us what excess K does to other nutrients too.
what is excessive

how many toxicities have you ever ran into, rare over here

K is very important as well

to much K will cuase Cal to not uptake

i can alwasy tell when im dealingwith growers who have tons of issues they chase, they think its abinary response add more K when not enough K, without understanding the role of micronutrients and how they are taken in and their relationships with media

yes excessive K can deplete cal in a soil, but thats why you only add the PK boosters at specific times when the pant can deal with the increase in avialble nutrients, also when its using less cal and nitrogen thus, which is another reason why you add P and K, P and nitrogen are protagonist and are absorbed together in ratios, less available N over time means a natural decrease in P, and same other way adding more P will increase uptake of N

often when you see a deficiency its actually nutrient antagonism from a competing element

when i hear growers say things like i have this or that without understanding the root issue , abiotic or biotic cause i cringe....
 

Samwell Seed Well

Well-Known Member
That’s not what he’s said. Sorry.

He said too much P or K can antagonise other nutrients.

my advice to anyone setting out growing for the first time is choose a basic nutrient that has everything the plant needs and become familiar with environmental control and manipulation.

Many new growers often look for a new bottle of something when in reality it could be an environmental issue causing problems.

Learn your nutrients

master your environmental variables.

THEN when you feel you’ve exhausted the resources available to you then look to add 1 additional product and see if it makes a difference.
he said imblance

and it doesnt, if you use it correctly

thats what im saying, just like any nutrient its effectiveness is all in how its used and could potentially cuase imbalances its a nothing burger

to much of anything use incorrectly will be bad

he is saying not to use it at all because it causes imbalances

it doesn't, thats not sound advice to anyone trying to use these products

and i fundamentally find fault with add 1 product and see how it works

you should know what to expect when ever using any product or dont use it

none of these things are new are special this is second oldest kind of business since the skin game we are not inventing things
 

Adi1989

Active Member
he said imblance

and it doesnt, if you use it correctly

thats what im saying, just like any nutrient its effectiveness is all in how its used and could potentially cuase imbalances its a nothing burger

to much of anything use incorrectly will be bad

he is saying not to use it at all because it causes imbalances

it doesn't, thats not sound advice to anyone trying to use these products

and i fundamentally find fault with add 1 product and see how it works

you should know what to expect when ever using any product or dont use it

none of these things are new are special this is second oldest kind of business since the skin game we are not inventing things
Would you say its time for me to use PK? Or should I wait a few more days / week?
 

Attachments

xtsho

Well-Known Member
I just feed my plants what they need to stay nice and healthy which isn't much. Plants create their own hormones even cannabis. No reason to be adding more. Some like to add this that and another thing trying to squeeze out an extra drop. In the end it's just money spent for little gain.

Use whatever you want on your plants. I'll KISS and end up with basically the same results without adding a bunch of stuff into the mix.
 

Samwell Seed Well

Well-Known Member
i actually use a 0-50-0 bloom boost at wk 4, i normally dont notice a need to boost K, in rockwool, but if i was in coco i would as K strips in coco as well

i use rockwool so the bloom booster i use is Bud Boost from Green Planet Nutrients, salts that need to be mixed and smell kinda like vegemite
Would you say its time for me to use PK? Or should I wait a few more days / week?
what week are you in, what are the genetics
 

Adi1989

Active Member
I just feed my plants what they need to stay nice and healthy which isn't much. Plants create their own hormones even cannabis. No reason to be adding more. Some like to add this that and another thing trying to squeeze out an extra drop. In the end it's just money spent for little gain.

Use whatever you want on your plants. I'll KISS and end up with basically the same results without adding a bunch of stuff into the mix.
Whats your regime xtsho?
 

Samwell Seed Well

Well-Known Member
thiers many ways to grow and get the same result mine work for me...

i have a back ground growing but in the last decade i switched my focus to IPM and production growing and it is slightly different.

we dont chase problems we grow through them, you dont fix plants when you have 5000 plants to take care of you work the room the zone.
 

Attachments

xtsho

Well-Known Member
Whats your regime xtsho?
Which one? I've been mostly doing organic using KNF and JADAM methods lately but those are too much trouble for a small indoor grow and are best left for a larger outdoor organic grow or for a vegetable garden. Prior to that I was growing in coco using just some basic nutrients with great results. My current indoor grow is in soil but my next is going to be back to coco and salt based nutrients. It's just easier and I don't feel like messing with stinky homemade organic fertilizer for my indoor plants.

Coco and just a basic nutrient that supplies what the plant needs is all that really needs to be done. Nutrients are not the first and foremost thing to be focused on. Used properly they'll all work. Focusing on environment and adequate lighting is more important than brand of nutrient or using additives. Environmental conditions are much more important than anything that comes in a bottle.

This is what I've used for years. Just a blend of cheap salts that provide everything the plant needs.

Nothing fancy and the Micro is similar to Jacks. Put out by what was the oldest hydro shop in Portland until they recently moved to Oregon City next to Flying Skull which makes Nuke Em and have a line of salt based nutrients that are descendents. VitaGrow has been used for decades by cannabis growers in the Portland area both small and large scale. It's all you need for a non-organic grow.

I can't find any information but it used to be called Golden Grow decades ago. Someone from the area might remember it.

 

Samwell Seed Well

Well-Known Member
Which one? I've been mostly doing organic using KNF and JADAM methods lately but those are too much trouble for a small indoor grow and are best left for a larger outdoor organic grow or for a vegetable garden. Prior to that I was growing in coco using just some basic nutrients with great results. My current indoor grow is in soil but my next is going to be back to coco and salt based nutrients. It's just easier and I don't feel like messing with stinky homemade organic fertilizer for my indoor plants.

Coco and just a basic nutrient that supplies what the plant needs is all that really needs to be done. Nutrients are not the first and foremost thing to be focused on. Used properly they'll all work. Focusing on environment and adequate lighting is more important than brand of nutrient or using additives. Environmental conditions are much more important than anything that comes in a bottle.

This is what I've used for years. Just a blend of cheap salts that provide everything the plant needs.

Nothing fancy and the Micro is similar to Jacks. Put out by what was the oldest hydro shop in Portland until they recently moved to Oregon City next to Flying Skull which makes Nuke Em and have a line of salt based nutrients that are descendents. VitaGrow has been used for decades by cannabis growers in the Portland area both small and large scale. It's all you need for a non-organic grow.

the grower at a farm i consult for uses vita. good stuff. def KISS
 
Top