CFLs starting i avg a oz per plant in 5 gallon planters .....standard box feed plan ( way off only the tops were tight the rest was fluffy joint/bho material '
LED rock my tight to fluffy has jumped to 90% tight 10% fluffy .....my yields were under that HIDs did for me but the better quality buds more then made up for less yield (then u factor in the life of the unit and the energy cost and the cooling/venting cost) i was doing 8 to 10 oz out of 7 gallons on auto plants
HIDs i was doing 10 to 14 oz out of 7 gallons ....the tight to fluffy was about 70%tight 30%fluffy (except with hydro that ended up being like 7% but i have not repeated that experiment so it could of just been a fluke)
the only limiting factor to LED is the over all area of coverage .....u can get more but u will end up given up some of the depth u gain with LED .....it is all matter of the lens angles
120 for wide print (widest possible u get a few more inches in depth compared to HIDs)
90 for small print but greater depth .......best deal over all area coverage with extended depth (2 3 grows in add a 2nd light u will get your large foot print)
60 for depth (u can grow grass under the plant assuming it not 6 feet tall)
the best was HID combined with LED side lights ......i want to try a dual arc bulb and a all spec led