HLG vs HGL Side By Side Take 2

Who do you think will win?

  • HLG

    Votes: 63 85.1%
  • HGL

    Votes: 11 14.9%

  • Total voters
    74
  • Poll closed .
Status
Not open for further replies.

Big Perm

Well-Known Member
Here's what I'm gonna do. I'll place plants in the new tent. I'll hang the hlg600 on one end and the other hps light (new/used light De 1000w with ballast, $120) on the other end, I'll use panda film to separate them (if possible) and compare Led to hps :cool:
You doing a journal on that?
 

Bourbon 2

Well-Known Member
a Led vs Hps grow? How innovating and shocking, i wonder which lamp is gonna win?
Ikr. But the HLG 600 QB advertises as follows so I really want to see for myself :weed:

HLG 600W LED kit has a output equivalent of 1000W DE HPS. 600W Kit is powered with our custom designed high efficiency QB288 V2 R spec Quantum Board.
 

OneHitDone

Well-Known Member
Which makes this side by side or thread shit show useless. And my kids have nothing to do with this you moron. Way to make yourself look as dumb as this side by side.
Hey bro, I don't know if that is even really your kids in the background of that pic and I truly meant no insult on you or your family. We are on a weed forum so we gotta protect our reality from what is seen online.
In the heat of the debate we all get wound up and just take shots at people some times and it's hard to read the sarcasm one was intending. Hopefully you can see that and I am sorry if you took it personal :peace:
 

Bourbon 2

Well-Known Member
Are you running with optimum environment for hps or led?
I finalized the installation of the new tent and setup. I decided to only run the HPS in the new tent for various reasons. Such as, it requires different air flow/circulation for the light fixture which changes the VFD for ambient temperature and RH. I already know what the HLG 600 yields in the best VFD environment/conditions (tent). So "no" journal, just curious which light produces the highest/gpw. My comparison study will be with a strain that seems to have solid averages of 8 ounces per plant w/hlg600. The strain is Chem Dog #4 by Growers Choice Seeds. I'll keep everyone updated with results. Cheers :peace:
 

Attachments

hybridway2

Amare Shill
View attachment 4359396

even with the best spectrum in the world, i’m SHOCKED!
Poeple, especially new growers to led. Do not listen to this Troll. That is not what LedDefficiency looks like & as a matter-o-fact this spectrum has not shown me any issues thus far.
Granted, i also chose this strain because I fealt she handles white led quite well.
Busy.
Why would you post that? Pls, dont even answer.
Red petitoles is natural here. Its dark purple stems im worried about & thus far both plants are doing well w/o them. Lil bit on the Trinity side as you can see from these clones that were taken from below, where the light barely hits. There's just a hint of purp on sides.

20190707_162257.jpg
 
Last edited:

OneHitDone

Well-Known Member
yup, only one page of threads anymore in its section, what happened over there @OneHitDone and @hybridway2? is it back in its old form again?
Thanks for looking out brother!
Everything is copacetic on the HGL front.
Here's a sneak peak of the XB35 Micro, XB70 Micro, and XB140 Micro for those following along with brother @hybridway2 's grow and interested in what the new product soon to be rolled out will look like :hump:

user430116_pic1959119_1562608270.jpg user430116_pic1959120_1562608270.jpg user430116_pic1959121_1562608270.jpg
 

Ryante55

Well-Known Member
Thanks for looking out brother!
Everything is copacetic on the HGL front.
Here's a sneak peak of the XB35 Micro, XB70 Micro, and XB140 Micro for those following along with brother @hybridway2 's grow and interested in what the new product soon to be rolled out will look like :hump:

View attachment 4362051 View attachment 4362052 View attachment 4362053
Nice she did everything the trolls wanted haha all that arguing and causing drama and she abandoned her original design she might actually have a good product now that she's doing something much more similar to hlg seems like a pretty fair price too
 

Norml56

Well-Known Member
Thanks for looking out brother!
Everything is copacetic on the HGL front.
Here's a sneak peak of the XB35 Micro, XB70 Micro, and XB140 Micro for those following along with brother @hybridway2 's grow and interested in what the new product soon to be rolled out will look like :hump:

View attachment 4362051 View attachment 4362052 View attachment 4362053
So before this side by side will even be completed HGL will have released a new light... Why would anyone buy the light that is being used for this grow?
 

hybridway2

Amare Shill
So before this side by side will even be completed HGL will have released a new light... Why would anyone buy the light that is being used for this grow?
They wouldn't. The point the seller is trying to make is that shes claiming she can outperform the latest n greatest using 6 yr old, 1.5 umol/j, RGB tech.
Imagine what the new t3ch could do, is where shes going with that.
She equated the results using the old tech to be 30-40% increase over opponent HLG'S TRINITY, Due to photosynthetic efficiency of the spectrum.
Personally, i think its gonna be close.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top