I give up, this is not for me...

bernie344

Well-Known Member
I want to start saying thanks to those who tried helping me, but I have a K deficient thumb and realize I will never be able to grow any plant in my life.

Today I'm chopping down my 420fastbuds autoflower. Growth has been stunted for a week now. I made a bunch of mistakes my first grow and corrected nearly all my mistakes with this second grow, but somehow it ended up... worse.

My first grow produced buds, but the autoflower giant (Big Bertha I called her) ended up 5' tall getting scorched by my 315 LEC. She may have also been over fed (full Lucas formula 0-8-16) since she was drinking so much from the intense light. I got A LOT of extracts off her to supply me for a long time so at least it wasn't a complete waste.

This second grow I ended up end gradually raising the nutrients to full lucas of 0-5-10 which she is at right now at ~600ppm being full week 5 today. Also bought a fancy HTG LED light to help me control light intensity and gives me more head room in case she turns into another giant. I also have a fancy ph meter along with a cheap one calibrated with all the nice calibration liquids. She has been sitting at 5.9 the whole time. Temperature has been 72-74 during the day and 68 at night. 40% humidity and the root appear to look great besides the discoloring that GH nutrients do to the roots.

Everyone says "ph issues" but sadly that is far from what is wrong. Being an analytical person, when I dial in the specifications needed to grow in DWC and things go south, I just have to give up. There is nothing else I can do, lucas formula works for people so I know its not that, GH nutrients work for people, so I know its not that. My only option would be to do something that is out of specifications which wouldn't make much sense.

Maybe I live in an area which a strong magnetic field, or maybe prone to solar flares. or maybe the stars awkwardly align in a way that makes plants unable to grow (which would explain all my grass and trees in my yard. Used RO water with calmag the whole time, so I know its not my water supply.

Sorry for the rant, mainly just here to say thanks, and that this community seems alright, it's just not for me. Pictures are before being chopped (Day 33). They looked like this for a week with no change even though they are drinking about a quarter gallon and the ppms drop maybe 30ppm a day. Looking at Growdiaries, even soil grow of this same strain had flowers at this point.

Anyone want a HTG LED light or a LEC? I'll give them away cheap (at least pay more than it cost to ship them).
Can you put up a link to your light?
 

natureboygrower

Well-Known Member
I literally put a seed in a pot outside last summer and watered it once in a while....
View attachment 4843135
Yes, thats misting water..... and yea... it was bagseed, and turned out to be a dude.... but not the point. Nature grew a plant, I just had to give it water because it's in a pot.... I think I gave it Miracle-Gro 15-30-15 Bloom once or twice through the summer.

I gave my friend one of my 2 month old indoor plants 3 months ago, as I didn't have room.
View attachment 4843143
He put it into flower, has it in his living room using window only for light and said he gave it tomato plant food once, otherwise just water. This is how it looked after a couple weeks. He said it's 5ft tall.
View attachment 4843137
And nope it's not going to produce big fat social media buds, again... not the point. Point is, it's growing and will finish, and with minimal involvement.

Treat it like a plant, specifically a flowering annual (Rosales), easy peasy.
Not everyone is happy with mids. I suppose if you dont set the bar too high, you'll never be disappointed. :-P
 

getogrow

Well-Known Member
DWC and all hydro is super easy. you have to follow ONE PERSONS directions because 10 different peoples methods do not work together.

If its something no one on the forum can figure out then your light is too bright. Thats almost more common then overwatering these days. SPECIALLY if you switched from hps or mh.
Other then that , do not take everyones advice but soak it in for future....
Pick one good dwc grower and follow them to the tee.

EDIT: Use a forum , NOT youtube. The guys here are more then willing to quide you through.
 

getogrow

Well-Known Member
After checking out your setup a bit more. i am confident you have too much light.
The rest is on whoever you are learning from. i see at least 3 or 4 things i would change but lets forget me and my assumptions,.... lets carry on to your problem. Temps are too low for leds. Your close to 10f from optimal so thats a big deal. She is so bushy that you wont see much growth while looking.

She has a couple hundred nodes to feed. If you want to SEE her grow then remove half the plant....clean her up a bit....take some branches off , leaves or whatever to open up some light to the middle. Once you have 10-50 branches then you can watch them grow. If you really wanna see a stretch right now then dim your lights to half. I would dim them to 60% ish just going by your info.

Id like to see the ph go from 5.9 to 6.5 or 7 before dropping it back down... That shouldnt make or break you if you do it or not.

That plant is way to happy to chop.
 

Jkooper

Active Member
After checking out your setup a bit more. i am confident you have too much light.
The rest is on whoever you are learning from. i see at least 3 or 4 things i would change but lets forget me and my assumptions,.... lets carry on to your problem. Temps are too low for leds.
Well, after looking at it all I do recall raising the light 4" last Thursday while taking the light from around 60% to max. I did that last grow but I switched from a 150W LED to a 315 LEC between week 4-5 and the plant turned into a monster yielding around 1lb. I figure I'd do the same expect instead of changing the light I just increase the intensity.

It was also growing in 24/0 prior to the light increase. When I increased the light I switched to 20/4. This LED should not be more powerful than the LEC. I didnt want a 5' plant so I decided to go with a "weaker" light. The light has always been 16" minimum from the top. But you are probably right, it could have been too much light I guess. I read that light stress if it even corrects itself would take 7-10 days. Thats pretty much a dead autoflower.
 

rkron0413

Well-Known Member
Because organic soil is extremely easy.
Unfortunately I can't grow worth a shit in soil. Same as op it sounds like. My first full cycle was dwc. Followed feed chart for the gh trio series and was using tap. Never checked my ppms and maybe checked my ph every water change. I've got very hard water. How is soil easier for someone who can't grow in soil?
 

dubekoms

Well-Known Member
Maybe I'll try using maxigro and try again. Why not autoflowers? I did the maxibloom equivelent but with the flora micro/bloom and the plant is completely stunted, for what appears to be no reason.
Maxigro and bloom will grow the plants perfectly. I use floranova bloom in veg and about 3 weeks into flower I switch to maxibloom. Autoflowers are tricky because they have a set life span, if you mess up for a couple weeks it affects the whole grow. Photoperiods are much more forgiving because if you stunt them in veg you can just keep vegging them until they grow out of it.
 

GrowdoBaggins

Well-Known Member
Unfortunately I can't grow worth a shit in soil. Same as op it sounds like. My first full cycle was dwc. Followed feed chart for the gh trio series and was using tap. Never checked my ppms and maybe checked my ph every water change. I've got very hard water. How is soil easier for someone who can't grow in soil?
How? Mix soil, or even easier, buy bag soil. Liquid seaweed, molasses and tap water. Top dress once a month or so. You don't even need to ph. Plus organic soil grown weed tastes so good. Less yield tho.
 

Jkooper

Active Member
Looks to me you're over thinking things. You should read my simple tutorial, and maybe something will click to make you go "Oh yeah". Then you'll restart all new in the mind, and a better idea where things went wrong. You don't need all that fancy stuff just paying attention to what the plant needs.

Simple Tutorial for Beginners: https://www.rollitup.org/t/simple-tutorial-for-beginners-using-hempy-lucas.911623/
Just an update after 16 hours (4 of those dark) after dimming the light to 60%, I see the flower at the tops along with growth :) See pic

Maybe its just stretch, but its better than nothing. I've seen a lot of tutorials but never came across yours. I guess I over looked:

"Get to know your specific lighting's penetration, sweetspot, and distance recommendations. "

I never used an LED this intense I guess. I went from a 150W to a 315 LEC last grow and the plant became nearly 5' tall immediately. I assumed plant of the same size could handle an LED of half the power at the same stage. I guess LED is a whole different animal.
 

Attachments

natureboygrower

Well-Known Member
No one cares for negative's, nature boy
If you got nothing to contribute to helping this guy NOT GIVE UP, please do.
How was I being negative? You posted a pic of a male plant and a small bud shot of a neglected plant growing next to a window. Im not sure how you were proving anything.

My original post to you wasn't negative either. It was realistic. Yeah, i get your whole dont love em to death pov, but you also cant ignore the possibility of the unexpected. Bad weather, power failure, out of wack well water, pests, mildew, mold, critters. It's part of growing. Especially outside growing.

contribute to helping this guy
I did. Coots mix soil ( water only, no bottled nutes) + SIPS planters. It does not get any easier. Dude said he overwaters soil. This method is pretty much foolproof when it comes to watering and you cannot overwater or under/over feed. If you cant store soil, then I understand not wanting to mix up your own, but if you can, it's just a matter of laying out a tarp and mixing the ingredients with a spade. No cook time required.
 

cjuneau1

Active Member
So the plant from my first grow became almost completely devoured by nitrogen toxicity. Also was messed up from changing the light schedule from 12/12 for the first 4 weeks to 24/0 for the 3 weeks after that. Anyone who knows anything knows that is totally wrong. With a ton of help from this forum, basically I stopped all liquid nutes and have been doing only ro water for four days now and 18/6 schedule. I can already in this short time see a huge difference in the new growth of my plant. If my plant can come back from the torture I put it through, you can grow some cannabis if you just don't give up my dude.
 

Gentlemencorpse

Well-Known Member
The only thing I've taken away from this thread is that at least one person thinks every growing method is the easiest lol

Seriously though OP, glad to see you didn't give up, you'll get there. I agree you should try growing a non-auto plant. New growers always think they will be easier, but I can tell you from experience that's usually not the case. Also, in your first post you say that your nutes can't be the problem because it works for others, and the Lucas formula can't be the problem, it works for others etc... ditch that mindset. Different strains respond differently to feed, lights, temps etc... one plant may love the full Lucas formula, the next may find it way too strong...
 

Bobobalast15

New Member
I want to start saying thanks to those who tried helping me, but I have a K deficient thumb and realize I will never be able to grow any plant in my life.

Today I'm chopping down my 420fastbuds autoflower. Growth has been stunted for a week now. I made a bunch of mistakes my first grow and corrected nearly all my mistakes with this second grow, but somehow it ended up... worse.

My first grow produced buds, but the autoflower giant (Big Bertha I called her) ended up 5' tall getting scorched by my 315 LEC. She may have also been over fed (full Lucas formula 0-8-16) since she was drinking so much from the intense light. I got A LOT of extracts off her to supply me for a long time so at least it wasn't a complete waste.

This second grow I ended up end gradually raising the nutrients to full lucas of 0-5-10 which she is at right now at ~600ppm being full week 5 today. Also bought a fancy HTG LED light to help me control light intensity and gives me more head room in case she turns into another giant. I also have a fancy ph meter along with a cheap one calibrated with all the nice calibration liquids. She has been sitting at 5.9 the whole time. Temperature has been 72-74 during the day and 68 at night. 40% humidity and the root appear to look great besides the discoloring that GH nutrients do to the roots.

Everyone says "ph issues" but sadly that is far from what is wrong. Being an analytical person, when I dial in the specifications needed to grow in DWC and things go south, I just have to give up. There is nothing else I can do, lucas formula works for people so I know its not that, GH nutrients work for people, so I know its not that. My only option would be to do something that is out of specifications which wouldn't make much sense.

Maybe I live in an area which a strong magnetic field, or maybe prone to solar flares. or maybe the stars awkwardly align in a way that makes plants unable to grow (which would explain all my grass and trees in my yard. Used RO water with calmag the whole time, so I know its not my water supply.

Sorry for the rant, mainly just here to say thanks, and that this community seems alright, it's just not for me. Pictures are before being chopped (Day 33). They looked like this for a week with no change even though they are drinking about a quarter gallon and the ppms drop maybe 30ppm a day. Looking at Growdiaries, even soil grow of this same strain had flowers at this point.

Anyone want a HTG LED light or a LEC? I'll give them away cheap (at least pay more than it cost to ship them).
Send it my way or try photoperiod. They tend to be easier to grow because of how forgiving the are
 

Wastei

Well-Known Member
DWC and hydroponics is easy if you follow basic principles and original system guidelines and not guidelines based on manufacturers marketing.

People miss what's good about hydro and believe they should mix dead mineral salts in readily available form with alive inoculants and organic acids for no real gain. It's a recipe for disaster. The older literature about hydro you read the better it is IMO. Real hydro(not coir) is supposed to be run sterile to be considered stable IMO.

Manufacturers want you to think hydro is a new thing when it's been used on a commercial scale for well over 50 years. Don't use dirt product and organics in DWC and pick a oxidizer of choice and get that on a shedule and dial it in. That's about it, cheers!
 
Top